Jump to content

thorpef1

Adding a sub to a stereo amplifier

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

HI all.

I have a stereo Setup (Denon DRA-375RD and Wharfedale Diamond 9.5) which i am relatively happy with for the time being (with the little one running around).

It is mainly used for music but is also plugged into the TV for when we watch movies. The room is around 20sqm

 

I was thinking of adding a smallish sub to compliment the system using high level inputs as the amp does not have a sub out.

 

What would people recommend for a sub $500 sub, i dont mind purchasing second hand as i will eventually do proper HT when the little one grows up a bit.

 

I would predominantly want it for music but also be able to perform when watching movies (that is more important than sounding good with movies and poor with music)

 

Cheers,

Luke 

 

Edited by thorpef1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rel is the most popular for music, probably T7i or 1003HT would be best for your purposes. SVS is another popular choice. 

 

Those look interesting as well. 

https://www.adelaidespeakers.com/subwoofers.html  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Velodyne, Krix, Focal etc and DIY designs on the net can done as well if you don’t need a certain appearance / pickup some good used subwoofer drivers and plate amp and build box.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for that guys, i might keep an eye out on the classifieds here.

I was considering DIY, but it looks like it will cost just as much (or more) than buying one second hand- yes i may get better components but its looking to max out the budget of $500.

 

I also assume no issues using the high level inputs to wire it in?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Do you have a LFE output on your receiver? That way you can just let the receiver control crossover etc. with just the one cable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, infinitelivez said:

Do you have a LFE output on your receiver

Unfortunately not

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
4 hours ago, thorpef1 said:

I also assume no issues using the high level inputs to wire it in?

Correct - no dramas with your Denon if using this connection method. High-level speaker inputs place an insignificant load on the amplifier (they are very high impedance) and your amp isn't a floating ground design. All good! :)

Edited by pete_mac

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, pete_mac said:

Correct - no dramas with your Denon if using this connection method.

Thanks Pete.

 

Also, any chance you are the same pete-mac from OzFoz?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Hi,

 

I’m using a REL T9i through high level inputs on my 2ch system. Works really well. Couldn’t live without it now. I also run my AVR into the .1 input for home theatre use so I’ve got the best of both worlds. 
 

Cheers. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
8 minutes ago, thorpef1 said:

Thanks Pete.

 

Also, any chance you are the same pete-mac from OzFoz?

 

Yessir!! Ha - I thought your username looked familiar!  :)

Edited by pete_mac

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have used Definitive Technology subs for a while. The smallest one is pretty good value, and they are quite musical.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

+1 for the RELs, with only an old Sansui sub for comparison. You can dial it down for music and up for movies. REL actually recommends you wire it up to your normal speaker connections using the Neutrik Speakon cable, so make sure that's included (or budget $80 to buy one).

Edited by David Walker
Minor correction

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Posted (edited)
On 29/06/2020 at 7:21 AM, thorpef1 said:

Thanks for that guys, i might keep an eye out on the classifieds here.

I was considering DIY, but it looks like it will cost just as much (or more) than buying one second hand- yes i may get better components but its looking to max out the budget of $500.

 

I also assume no issues using the high level inputs to wire it in?

DIY is still worth go such as $213  https://www.altronics.com.au/p/a2451-opus-one-180w-active-subwoofer-amplifier/ and occasional offerings on gumtree like quality Peerless xLs 12 subwoofers and similar for around $150 used, MDF cabinet $70 for materials from Bunnings or even less in gumtree. If you don’t need huge Xmax and earth shattering volumes there are many hifi woofers that give very detailed music performance such old venerable Kef 139 oval woofers, Focal Kevlar 10-12 inch, other Peerless 12 inch, several latest offerings from Dayton, Eton and Scanspeak etc from $50-300 used. Use an online speaker box volume design calculator to size the cabinet like WINISD.

 

Can even try transmission line cabinet designs with very good results if you have space for large cabinet.

Edited by Al.M

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 29/06/2020 at 5:06 PM, Jhsg said:

Hi,

 

I’m using a REL T9i through high level inputs on my 2ch system. Works really well. Couldn’t live without it now. I also run my AVR into the .1 input for home theatre use so I’ve got the best of both worlds. 
 

Cheers. 

Not every subwoofer can be directly connected to 2 amplifiers at the same time. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guys.

I have set up some alerts for Rel, SVS and also Richter to see what pops up.

 

I have also come across the below busted JBL sub which isnt too far away.

Pending the amp is working fine, what sort of driver would be a good replacement for this amp and box volume (happy to fill the port if a sealed box is more appropraite:

https://www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/hoxton-park/speakers/jbl-pb12-12-250-watt-down-firing-powered-subwoofer-need-repair-/1247742244 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, thorpef1 said:

Thanks guys.

I have set up some alerts for Rel, SVS and also Richter to see what pops up.

 

I have also come across the below busted JBL sub which isnt too far away.

Pending the amp is working fine, what sort of driver would be a good replacement for this amp and box volume (happy to fill the port if a sealed box is more appropraite:

https://www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/hoxton-park/speakers/jbl-pb12-12-250-watt-down-firing-powered-subwoofer-need-repair-/1247742244 

By the time you ll try to fix it, it might be easier to get that one.

https://www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/punchbowl/speakers/velodyne-impact-12-subwoofers/1251311942

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


1 hour ago, thorpef1 said:

Pending the amp is working fine, what sort of driver would be a good replacement

The amplifier will contain specific EQ for the driver/box it was designed for......   so only the original driver will be a reliable replacement.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Irek said:

By the time you ll try to fix it, it might be easier to get that one.

https://www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/punchbowl/speakers/velodyne-impact-12-subwoofers/1251311942

Good spot, as it is still a current model sub i may go and see how it sounds before i grab this one.

 

23 minutes ago, davewantsmoore said:

The amplifier will contain specific EQ for the driver/box it was designed for......   so only the original driver will be a reliable replacement.

That was the sort of information i was looking for, so sounds like buying older subs with dead drivers isnt an option

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, thorpef1 said:

so sounds like buying older subs with dead drivers isnt an option

Generally, yes.  It depends.

 

Most subwoofers have specific EQ applied to the driver, so that the combined response of the amp/driver/box is flat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, thorpef1 said:

Good spot, as it is still a current model sub i may go and see how it sounds before i grab this one.

 

That was the sort of information i was looking for, so sounds like buying older subs with dead drivers isnt an option

You may be able to get a driver that is close enough but the driver itself could be setting you back more than buying a working used sub. If you were going down the path of replacing a driver you would need to either do a 1 for 1 replacement of same  brand and model or run simulations with software to find a suitable replacement.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

The used JBL sub looks like about $800 rrp 2000 model with about 46L internal volume ported design. A repairer might be able to fix the woofer if it is burnt voice coil for maybe $120+ unless the problem is the amp unit then more. It’s really only worth about $50 in that condition with unknown repairs.

 

A Peerless 12 xls woofer is a possible replacement, most 12 inch hifi speaker woofers would be designed for a 75L+/- ported enclosure to get the desired low freq response unless the EQ in the subamp unit kicks it lower. There may be used specific or similar woofer replacements elsewhere on eBay etc. Note the JBL woofer is downfiring with thick roll surround to keep it in place vs other replacement woofers that may not be good for downfiring due to gravity pulling cone down in the long term.

 

A good place to look for possible replacement model woofers is download the free speaker design software WINISD http://www.linearteam.org which has a large data base for possibly 80-90% of woofers ever made and used by manufacturers. If you get the JBL look on the back of the woofer for make and model number. A smaller 8-10 inch woofer might cope given the 47L cabinet volume and retain similar low freq extension but a new panel would be needed to seal it.

 

Most of this too much trouble. There is a Gumtree Sony SAWM40 sub somewhere for $120 which I often recommend to people.

Edited by Al.M

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for that detailed response AI.M.

 

I don't mind playing around on WINISD (I remember building my car subwoofer years ago) but if it limits my options due to amp and volume it may be easier to find a working one. 

 

So I have bookmarked a few of the velodyne impact 12"

I have also come across the below two and wondering how these would go:

 

KEF psw4000

Focal chorus sw700s

 

What's the consensus on the velodyne vs kef vs focal?

 

I'm also keeping an eye out for a rel 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bump.

 

Whats the consensus on the below:

Velodyne Impact 12 

KEF PSW4000

Focal Chorus SW700S.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, thorpef1 said:

Bump.

 

Whats the consensus on the below:

Velodyne Impact 12 

KEF PSW4000

Focal Chorus SW700S.

 

 

 

From what I've read (no personal experience) the SW700S is quite a tight and dry-sounding woofer, not a boomer. Great for music, and good for home theatre, but not necessarily an outright bruiser.

 

I've repaired KEF subwoofers in the past - the earlier 10" versions often suffered from age-related issues due to a compromised design, but the later models might have rectified this.

 

I have no personal experience with Velodynes.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

theres a subsonic that might interest. as an aussie sub brand quite well made and pretty good quality at a great price here.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Classifieds Statistics


    Currently Active Ads

    Total Sales (Since 2018)

    Total Sales Value (Last 14 Days)

    Total Ads Value (Since March 2020)
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By mfroes
      Hi Guys,
      another newbie question.
      I've been after some speaker wire. i've seen people use cat5/cat6 and all that but i think i'd just stick to standard speaker wires.
      I'll be using the furthest speaker with about 17-18m because of how the speaker wire needs to be routed.
      All speakers are rated at 150W but the Front ones that are rated at 250W.
      the amp will be set under the TV and the only wires to be routed to the right will be the front right and the Surround right
      all other ones will have to be routed through the left  passing from the TV through Subwoofer, front left, surround left, back left and back right (about 17m)
      unfortunately the house is rented and i cannot drill foor/wall/ceiling.
       
      I've read online that i would need 14 Gauge wiring for the speakers but didnt say anything about distance. was just power and ohms.
       
      Would it be ok to use 12Gauge instead of 14 gauge? would that have any implications ?
      or better to just stick with 14 gauge? 
       
      would anyone have any suggestions on wire to buy that wouldnt be that expensive?
       
      what are the thoughts on ugly?
      https://www.selby.com.au/brands/ugly-cable/ugly-12-awg-speaker-cable-420-strands-ug12.html
       
      have anyone used knukonceptz ?
      http://www.knukonceptz.com/home-theater/speaker-wire/kord-speaker-wire/sp/kord-ultra-flex-12-gauge-speaker-wire-100/
       
      I think i'll need in total about 70-75m of wiring so can get expensive fast.
      the idea is to use banana plugs for everything.
      i would probably use the same wire with RCA connector for the sub.
       
      current setup:
      Front: NHT C4
      Centre: Gale 20
      Back & Surround: Axis LS28
      Subwoofer: Sound Dynamics THS-10
       
                               TV
      FL   S                C                     FR
       
       
      SL                                              SR
       
       
      BL                                             BR
       
       
      distance from amp:
      C(enter): 3-4m to be able to route through the tv unit
      S(ub):  4m
      FL: 5m
      FR: 6m
      SL: 10m
      SR: 12m
      BL: 14m
      BR: 18m
    • By JimmyDee
      Item Condition: 3 yrs old - Perfect working order Shipping Options: Pickup available and you can audition.,Shipping is available at agreed cost. Suburb or Town: Perth State: Western Australia Payment Method: Paypal, EFT, Cash Reason for selling: No longer required Further information: 
      70W/channel Stereo Amp and DAC. Great for hook-up to a digital source (ie computer, tablet, pod, CD player) and bypass their inbuilt DAC to utilise this far superior one.
      The USB D/A converter is the 32-bit high-performance SABRE 32 from ESS Technology, and its USB device controller IC is the latest product from XMOS, the semiconductor firm. It is compatible with native playback of the DSD 5.6MHz (DSD128) format or 384kHz/32-bit playback. Supported formats are:
      MP3, WMA, MPEG4, AAC, WAV, FLAC, AIFF, ALAC, DSD – 192 kHz / 24bit; 96 kHz / 24 bit; 5.6 MHz
      Few minor scratches on top cover.
      Photos: Advertisements without photos of the actual item will not be approved.




    • By Bush thug
      So i searched the web trying to find the best way to set up a subwoofer with a variable phase dial for a 2 channel system as i was having difficulties, when i stumbled accross this and thought it might interest people.
      Pretty easy and makes sense really. i got the same results set to 140 and  they are perfectly in sync and sounds the best i have heard my set up its amazing. If anyone else has any worthwhile hacks i would love to here them.
      Also curious as quite new to subwoofers why all subs dont have a variable phase?
       
      He used this audio cd to find the frequency he needed
      https://www.amazon.com/Sheffield-A2TnB-Test-Disc-My/dp/B000V93NKY
      I just used this one and selected the range i wanted to use
       
      This is a quote straight from the post.
      Most subwoofer users understand the need for a continuously variable phase control to help greatly with the setup and integration with the main speakers. (FYI setting crossover and levels is easier to do and should be done first) .
      In the past I have used room measurements to set the phase control- rotate the knob until the response is flattest- with decent success.
      More recently I used the concept of "timing" the subwoofer and main speakers by playing a track with constant beats- then rotating the phase control until it sounds synchronized or strongest. This worked well but seems to work better with limited range monitor speakers and not so well with fuller range towers.
      Many sites suggest that you "adjust until the bass sounds loudest" . This isn't the best idea because you could be adjusting such that you are creating a summed peak in the response.
      Having just added (2) subs to my system I recalled my mobile audio days as to how to best set the phase of the subwoofers. Here is what I did (two subwoofers). You can use the same method with a single sub as well.
      1) Reverse the leads of the main speakers so that (+) goes to (-) and vice versa.
      2) Shift balance to that side (e.g. right speaker, right sub)
      3) Use a demo disk (see below) and play the test tone that corresponds to your crossover frequency. In my case the frequency is 63Hz.
      4) Rotate the phase control gradually until the tone is as silent as possible at your listening position. The main will be out of phase with the sub and the two will cancel each other.
      I did this with the right sub/speaker set and the 63Hz tone became silent between 120 -degrees and 160 -degrees on the app / dial. I set it to 14o degrees, dead even between the two.
      For the left speaker and sub the 63Hz tone became silent at 180-degrees.
      5) Reverse the leads back to normal on the main speakers- and WOW! A completely integrated and sweet sounding speaker system! The bass became smooth, continuous, warm and effortless. Punches are completely in sync and powerful without effort, sustained notes are smooth and decay so naturally. There are no signs of separation between subs and mains. They act as "one" more than I have ever heard.
      By far the best method i have ever used to integrate a subwoofer.


       
    • By Jobin
      Item:
      Price Range:
      Item Condition: New or Used
      Extra Info:I have a Klipsch 25 c centre,floor standing 28 icon series. 14s surrounds.sw 450 sub. The sub is good more movies but not that good for music. Looking to upgrade  with an enclosed sub.suggestions please. I have svs sb2000 in mind
      Please don't forget to report your post as FOUND when possible. (You can now delete this text).
    • By hifiman
      Item Condition: Very good Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available. Suburb or Town: Melbourne Eastern suburbs State: Victoria Payment Method: EFT/Cash on pickup Reason for selling: NLR Further information: 
      Re-posted with lower price.
      Cherry wood veneer color. This is the first edition that uses a bigger box, down-firing. It makes for a good looking side table! 
      Review of this edition link below:
      https://hometheaterhifi.com/volume_13_1/svs-pb12-plus-subwoofer-1-2006-part-1.html
       
      Photos: Advertisements without photos of the actual item will not be approved.




×
×
  • Create New...