Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

 

Need some advise and guidance regarding the power amplifier requirements for home theatre use.

 

I have Anthem MRX710 powering my 7.1 setup in Home theatre, my components are as below.

 

Fronts: Ascension Summoner 863SQTL (150 WRMS, with 91 dB 1w/1m sensitivity)

Center: Ascension 253SQ (120/200 wrms/max (@ 60Hz plus), , with 91 dB 1w/1m sensitivity) 

Surrounds: Polk T15 (20 watts → 100 watts, with 89 db 1w/1m sensitivity)

Surround back (Ceiling mounted): Micca M-8C (100 watts, with 90dB 1W/1M sensitivity)

Subwoofer: Martin Logan Dynamo 600x

Room size: 4m x 3.8m (Acoustically treated with Acoustic pin boards, Martini Absorb HD50 on all 4 walls with carpet on the floor, ceiling untreated.)

 

I like loud volumes when watching movies to get the same feel and punch one gets from commercial theatres. However, I have never gone past -10db volume level with Anthem, as I find other members of the household start complaining before I even get a chance to listen at reference level. This is for mainly HT use, I do occasionally listen to two channel music but it is not my main stereo listening room.

 

Some demo audio at close to reference level sounds amazing and feel like increasing the volume even more, however I find some movie scenes at the loud volume seems to be bit distorted or somewhat incoherent that I find the need to turn down the volume. I am not sure, if this is the limiting factors of Anthem's power amp stage or just room acoustics.

 

So far, Anthem has been the best AVR, I have ever had and Sound quality is really really great. Lately, I have been questioning, if I should add a power amplifier to the mix, and if I did, will there be much improvements to the sound quality vs the money spent? I am mainly thinking about adding 2 or 3 channel amp for front stage. I have seen countless posts on the net where people suggest adding power amp to AVR to boost the sound quality, given the Anthem MRX710 driving 7 channels, I don't think it outputs more than 80-90 watts per channel. 

 

Will adding power amp to my setup give me better bang for buck?

 

As for the budget, It is very limited at this stage and I am thinking somewhere the range of $1000 for 3 channels. Unfortunately, most in this range are somewhat at the same power rating as the Anthem or less, that I think will not make much difference adding them.

 

What do you guys recommend, Is power amp really necessary and will it be a better investment? if so, what amps would you recommend to go with Anthem MRX710? 

Anthem's MCA325 is an ideal choice to match with Anthem MRX but at $3600, it is way out of budget for me. Should I get some inexpensive amp now or perhaps I should save up and go for it when budget allows and be done with it or I am looking at this at wrong way and should perhaps target my speakers. I am quite happy with the front stage, my surrounds are cheap speakers, but they do their job.

 

What has been your experience when adding the power amp to relieve AVR of some of the channels?

Edited by N_R
Updated subwoofer information
Link to post
Share on other sites

Consider adding subwoofer(s) instead and setting your speakers to "small" with a crossover set in the AVR to 80Hz.

This will significantly reduce the effort required by your speakers and therefore AVR especially playing movie soundtracks with LFE content.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Satanica said:

Consider adding subwoofer(s) instead and setting your speakers to "small" with a crossover set in the AVR to 80Hz.

This will significantly reduce the effort required by your speakers and therefore AVR especially playing movie soundtracks with LFE content.

Oops, I forgot to include the subwoofer in the components. Yes, I do have a subwoofer and checked the Anthem's ARC setting and it has set the crossover to 80hz.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, N_R said:

Oops, I forgot to include the subwoofer in the components. Yes, I do have a subwoofer and checked the Anthem's ARC setting and it has set the crossover to 80hz.

OK cool. Do you have all speakers set to "small"?

Link to post
Share on other sites


1 minute ago, Satanica said:

OK cool. Do you have all speakers set to "small"?

Yes, all speakers are set to small and crossover set at 80hz.

 

I do find the balance between subwoofer and speakers are good, no complains there. The sub also has Anthem room correction built in so it does work perfectly in the room. Its just at the loud volume, I am finding the amp's power stage starts to lose the control a little bit. That's not to say it does not sound good, I am just questioning if adding a power amp to mix will improve the performance. Given the cost of the power amps, I am evaluating if the cost is worth it to over all improvement. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

The MRX-710 does have decent power, 90W over 5 channels (when they used to declare multi channel power). Your speakers are also sensitive.  I suspect any gain with a power amp will not be that significant?

 

Suggest instead to get a second sub. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
27 minutes ago, Snoopy8 said:

The MRX-710 does have decent power, 90W over 5 channels (when they used to declare multi channel power). Your speakers are also sensitive.  I suspect any gain with a power amp will not be that significant?

 

Suggest instead to get a second sub. 

Thank you for suggestions.

 

Adding a second sub would be bit of a pain. Room is not that huge for a second sub, also MRX710 has only one Sub out. I could get a RCA splitter but, I fear this way the ARC room correction would screwup. Besides, I really would not prefer to add a second sub. I am quite happy with the current bass output, its not boomy and doesn't vibrate things unnecessary. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, N_R said:

Adding a second sub would be bit of a pain. Room is not that huge for a second sub, also MRX710 has only one Sub out. I could get a RCA splitter but, I fear this way the ARC room correction would screwup. Besides, I really would not prefer to add a second sub. I am quite happy with the current bass output, its not boomy and doesn't vibrate things unnecessary. 

I used to own a MRX-710 and ran with 2 subs. Use a Y-splitter (which is internal in the latest Anthem AVRs) and it is easy to integrate the subs using ARC.

https://www.pooraudiophile.com/2014/06/how-to-calibrate-dual-subwoofers-with.html

(I took my integration further using a DSP, but that is for another discussion).

 

Also, have you looked at tweaking ARC to get more slam

https://www.anthemarc.com/arc-genesis/advanced-settings/adjust-arc-settings-adjust-targets.php

I have used a target curve which boosts the bass between 4 to 8 dB, starting around 200 Hz and going down.  At about 30 Hz, decay it rapidly (but never abruptly).  You can experiment with different values and you can try one or other, or both.

image.png.ea053969552d766d2150781c74fc18f0.png

 

Link to post
Share on other sites


18 minutes ago, Snoopy8 said:

I used to own a MRX-710 and ran with 2 subs. Use a Y-splitter (which is internal in the latest Anthem AVRs) and it is easy to integrate the subs using ARC.

https://www.pooraudiophile.com/2014/06/how-to-calibrate-dual-subwoofers-with.html

(I took my integration further using a DSP, but that is for another discussion).

 

Also, have you looked at tweaking ARC to get more slam

https://www.anthemarc.com/arc-genesis/advanced-settings/adjust-arc-settings-adjust-targets.php

I have used a target curve which boosts the bass between 4 to 8 dB, starting around 200 Hz and going down.  At about 30 Hz, decay it rapidly (but never abruptly).  You can experiment with different values and you can try one or other, or both.

image.png.ea053969552d766d2150781c74fc18f0.png

 

Thank you for the suggestions Snoopy. Yes, I did adjust the ARC to tweak to my liking. I think I may not have phrased the topic right.

 

I am quite happy with the current setup as is, with the Sub and ARC adjustments, there is just right amount of punch and balance between speakers and sub that I like and don't think I need anymore bass output. What my concern is that when I turn up the volume close to reference level, I do notice the audio seems to be little distorted, I took this to mean the power amp stage is at its limit in terms of pushing the speakers.

 

I may be wrong here, and the amp might just be powerful enough to drive the speakers.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
26 minutes ago, N_R said:

What my concern is that when I turn up the volume close to reference level, I do notice the audio seems to be little distorted, I took this to mean the power amp stage is at its limit in terms of pushing the speakers.

 

I may be wrong here, and the amp might just be powerful enough to drive the speakers.

It may be the amp or it may not. As you ask more of your speakers the drivers have to increase in excursion. In general, increased driver excursion means increased distortion.

 

If you did get an amplifier which I'm not sure whether to suggest or not, I would suggest you get one that is capable of at least twice power so that it is capable of providing a 3db increase which is twice the acoustic power (intensity). Note this would not provide twice the volume, you need a 10db increase for that. For three channels and $1000 I think you're looking at second hand and you have to factor in the cost of interconnects. Three channel amps are not common. If you bought a second hand one, tried it and found it offered no value you could probably on sell it for around what you bought it for.

Edited by Satanica
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, N_R said:

What my concern is that when I turn up the volume close to reference level, I do notice the audio seems to be little distorted, I took this to mean the power amp stage is at its limit in terms of pushing the speakers.

Sorry, I missed that!  In that case, with your budget, get a second hand 3 channel power amp, probably a Rotel or Emotiva. Anthem power amps do not appear often here.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites


16 hours ago, N_R said:

What are your thoughts on pro audio power amps? They seem to be a lot cheaper with lot of power outputs.

 

Something like this seems powerful enough.

https://www.storedj.com.au/crown-xli800-power-amplifier-2x-300w-4ohm

 

or are they not suitable for home use?

Interesting I thought of suggesting pro as such, but I was reluctant for several reasons. Mostly because you said you wanted a three channel amp and pro amps are seemingly almost exclusively 2 channel.

 

I have three of these:

https://www.storedj.com.au/crown-xls1502-power-amplifier-2x-525w-4ohm?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIu-Ds2vXS6QIVR3RgCh2lHg-QEAYYBCABEgLuR_D_BwE

Two of them power the woofers of my main speakers and one powers my surround speakers in my 4.2 setup.

Review here:

https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/review-and-measurements-of-crown-xls-1502-amp.6062/

 

Things to consider of pro amps which may be viewed as negative.

1) They may do an analogue to digital and then digital to analogue conversion even when there are no settings applied i.e. no analog bypass. The XLS 1502 as mentioned above is one as such.

2) They usually have fans and they can be audible. The XLS 1502 is not one as such as the fans only come on when needed and even when they do are extremely quiet in that I've never heard them from my listening position.

3) They can have much more lighting than domestic amps. The XLS 1502 is one as such out of the box but you can switch them all of by delving into the settings!

Edited by Satanica
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Satanica said:

Interesting I thought of suggesting pro as such, but I was reluctant for several reasons. Mostly because you said you wanted a three channel amp and pro amps are seemingly almost exclusively 2 channel.

 

I have three of these:

https://www.storedj.com.au/crown-xls1502-power-amplifier-2x-525w-4ohm?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIu-Ds2vXS6QIVR3RgCh2lHg-QEAYYBCABEgLuR_D_BwE

Two of them power the woofers of my main speakers and one powers my surround speakers in my 4.2 setup.

Review here:

https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/review-and-measurements-of-crown-xls-1502-amp.6062/

 

Things to consider of pro amps which may be viewed as negative.

1) They may do an analogue to digital and then digital to analogue conversion even when there are no settings applied i.e. no analog bypass. The XLS 1502 as mentioned above is one as such.

2) They usually have fans and they can be audible. The XLS 1502 is not one as such as the fans only come on when needed and even when they do are extremely quiet in that I've never heard them from my listening position.

3) They can have much more lighting than domestic amps. The XLS 1502 is one as such out of the box but you can switch them all of by delving into the settings!

Thank you for the tip Satanica,

 

This one does seem like a good amp. I have always wondered, why aren't these powerful pro audio amps being used in HT setup. I might as well just get this one and if I like get another just to drive the centre channel.

Link to post
Share on other sites


Novice question here folks and apologies if it sounds nonsensicle.

When adding a power amp to your AVR or Integrated amp does the sound signature change?

 

By that I mean, take an AVR like Anthem, Marantz and Yamaha who all have for want of a better term a different sound - will the power amp influence that house sound?

 

For an integrated amp, again, adding in power amp to something like I have the Vincent SV237mkII which first 10w class A and has tubes and SS.  Adding in a power amp to provide more drive much like the OP will the Class A disappear and or the sound signature change from the Vincent Sound.

 

Hope this isnt a derail, its a question I've often wondered and with the OP looking to add more power to his Anthem I thought it a good time to ask and learn

 

cheers.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, 08Boss302 said:

Novice question here folks and apologies if it sounds nonsensicle.

When adding a power amp to your AVR or Integrated amp does the sound signature change?

 

By that I mean, take an AVR like Anthem, Marantz and Yamaha who all have for want of a better term a different sound - will the power amp influence that house sound?

 

For an integrated amp, again, adding in power amp to something like I have the Vincent SV237mkII which first 10w class A and has tubes and SS.  Adding in a power amp to provide more drive much like the OP will the Class A disappear and or the sound signature change from the Vincent Sound.

 

Hope this isnt a derail, its a question I've often wondered and with the OP looking to add more power to his Anthem I thought it a good time to ask and learn

 

cheers.

As far as I know, power amp should not add any coloration, if it does it’s not a good amp. It’s only job is to provide power, a good amp is good at providing dynamic power when and if needed, nothing else.


Tube amp would be different to that generalisation.

 

no worries about side questions, I welcome it, helps me learn more.

Edited by :) Go Away (:
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you!  I appreciate the reply.   Yeah, its one of the things i've been wondering about for some time.

I've often pondered on getting a power amp for my integrated just for extra drive as the volume gets to a point where  it seems to run of puff.....to be fair its not often I push it that hard but when I want to ensure I keep the first 10watts as Class A and dont want any colouration influence from the power amp.  My integrated has tubes but its not strict tube amp.  I'll dig around the net and see if I can find more information on that

 

cheers.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...
On 28/05/2020 at 2:59 PM, :) Go Away (: said:

Hey @Satanica, I ended up placing an order for Crown XLS 1502, now the waiting game begins for postie to show up.

 

Question, what sensitivity setting I should be using, I have no idea what that does.

Hi, note that the sensitivity can be set to 1.4Vrms or 0.775Vrms and that the latter will yield 6db worse signal to noise ratio (more hiss).

I suggest the 1.4Vrms setting.

The only potential downside is that your pre-amp outputs less than 1.4Vrms at maximum (e.g. 1.0Vrms max) and this would mean you won't be able to drive the amplifier to full power with this setting. But with the amount of power this amplifier is capable of I doubt it will be a problem.

So I suggest you start with 1.4Vrms and if you think you're not getting enough power out of it change it to 0.775Vrms.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By xPLAYRZx
      Item Condition: Excellent Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available.,Shipping is included in price. Suburb or Town: Traralgon State: VIC Payment Method: Direct deposit, PayID (preferred), PayPal (+fees) Reason for selling: NLR Further information: Up for sale is my Anthem AVM60 processor.  Unit is approx 12-18 months old and is in excellent condition.  Includes ARC kit and all original accessories, manuals and box.  Shipping via insured courier is included to anywhere in Australia.
       
      Full product details and specs available from Anthem - https://www.anthemav.com/products-archived/model=avm-60/page=overview
       
      Photos:
       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       
    • By OzJustin
      Hi all,
       
      After persevering with a funny L-shaped theatre room for the last few years, I'm finally moving into a better room for my theatre room. This room has its own quirks but will be much closer to a rectangle and will allow me to have much better speaker placement. It's an existing living room so I'm not looking for anything radical with the design, just some advice on key points to have it work effectively for the future.
       
      Key details:
      6.9m (length) x 5m (width) x 2.45m (height)
      One set of glass french doors on the main viewing wall, one window on the left wall, one door on the right wall, one door in the back wall, two ceiling beams running across the ceiling at the 2.5m and 5m mark with the beams dropping down approx 230mm,  oh and a funny study corner room (which actually works very well for my design which will have a fixed frame screen on castors to slide it out of the way of the french doors).
      Will be a light controlled room with black blockout curtains, but will be a light and bright living room when not in theatre use. Will be a combo of movies, tv, music and gaming.
      140" 16:9 fixed frame screen with acoustic transparent fabric
      One lounge row of seating approx 4 - 4.5m back from the screen, and perhaps some bean bags around the room as extra occassional seating.
      Currently 7.1 channel 1080P with a BenQ W1070, but am prepping the room for potentially 7.2.4 down the track with a BenQ W5700 or similar 4K projector. Will probably stay with the 140" 16:9 screen but could transition to a 180" 2.35:1 cinemascope screen down the track if I was feeling really adventurous.
       
      Key initial questions:
      For a 4 - 4.5m viewing distance from screen, should I aim for the projector to be approx. 4.5m back from the screen (within BenQ's min and max specs for a 140" (3544 - 4608mm)? Will I be right with the lense centre point approx 20cm below the ceiling? (Noting beam no.1 drops down approx 230mm and is well in front of the projector). I propose for the top of screen to be approx 350 - 450mm below the ceiling line when in position. If I run 4 x Atmos speakers in the ceiling in future (leaning towards Krix Helix due to their shallow 86mm mounting depth), I assume I will have to run two approx 1.5m in front of my lounge, and then the other two 1.5m behind my lounge to align with Dolby's 90 degree placement? Am I likely to have sound issues with ceiling beam no.2  partially blocking the listening position or due to the speakers not being far from the back wall?  Any thoughts on the use of a solid core sliding door for the right side door? Can you get a drop seal for this kind of door to minimise sound leakage? I'm working out wiring now. Some cables will use cable hide strips along the skirting boards while I think I'll need 1-2 runs of cable to the ceiling (for the projector and Atmos speakers) and right wall (for the rear right and rear surround right speakers). Should I be adding any specific cables now to future-proof the ceiling inputs for a projector e.g. 10-15m long HDMI, cat5e, power, displayport? What will be the common projector standard in say 3 years time?  
      Pictures to aid discussion: (note my horribly rough hand drawn plan is not at all to scale!)



      Random idea for the sliding door:


       
      Thanks  
    • By OzJustin
      Item Condition: Very good working condition Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available. Suburb or Town: Springwood State: QLD Payment Method: Cash on Pickup Reason for selling: No longer required Further information:
       
      Selling my Anthem MRX 300 AV Receiver
       
      This is an amazing 7 channel receiver for movies and music and puts previous Yamaha, Onkyo etc receivers I've had to shame. The inbuilt amplifier is far more powerful than the specs would suggest and the Anthem Room Correction (ARC) really improves the sound. It also has 7 channel pre-outs so can be used with separate power amplifiers if desired.
       
      The unit is in very good working condition.
       
      Included is the complete kit comprising of the main unit and power cable, Anthem primary remote and zone 2 remote, AM/FM antennas, ARC kit (including calibration microphone, tripod and cables).
       
      Also included is a Tripp-Lite Keyspan USA-19HS USB Serial Adapter. This allows you to connect the unit to modern PC's via USB rather than the older style serial cable that most modern PC's no longer have. Most of the MRX x00 series for sale do not include this adapter. They are about $80 each.
      https://www.tripplite.com/keyspan-high-speed-usb-to-serial-adapter~USA19HS
       
      Specifications:
      https://anthemav.com/products-archived/type=av-receiver/model=mrx-300/page=overview
      Specs
      Audio Decoding:
      DOLBY: TrueHD, Digital 5.1, EX, Pro Logic IIz, Volume, Virtual Speaker
      DTS: DTS-HD Master Audio, DTS, ES, 96/24, Neo:6
      OTHER: AnthemLogic-Music, AnthemLogic-Cinema
      3D: Yes
      THX Certification: No
      Number of Amp Channels: 7
      Rated Power (watts per channel): 80 into 8 ohms, 2 channels driven; 60 into 8 ohms, 5 channels driven
      Specified Frequency Response: 20 Hz to 20 kHz (+0/–0.25 dB)
      Video Processing: Genesis Torino
      Auto Setup/Room EQ: Anthem Room Correction
      Dimensions (W x H x D, inches): 17.25 x 6.5 x 15.25
      Weight (pounds): 33.4
       
      Connections
      Inputs: Video: HDMI 1.4a (4), component video (3), composite video (4)
      Audio: Coaxial digital (2), optical digital (3), stereo analog (7), 1/4-inch headphone
      Additional: AM (1), FM (1), IR (1)
      Accessory: Anthem dock (1)
      Outputs: Video: HDMI 1.4a (1), component video (1), composite video (3)
      Audio: Coaxial digital (1), optical digital (1), stereo analog (3), 7.1-channel preamp (1)
      Additional: RS-232 (1), 12-volt trigger (1), IR (2)
       
      Photos:

       

       

       

       

       

       

       
    • By AgentFly
      Item Condition: Excellent Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available. Suburb or Town: Thornbury State: VIC Payment Method: Paypal or Cash on Pickup Reason for selling: It was my deceased father's and it's too complicated for me! Up for sale: Top of the range model Anthem MRX 700

      Receiver works perfectly, as you can see in the photos, it's in excellent condition, well cared for and loved by my now deceased father who purchased it new.

      Fantastic sound quality.

      Included:

      - Receiver

      - Unit remote plus bonus surround sound/media remote

      - Cables as photographed

      - Operating manual in both English and French!

      Item location Thornbury VIC
       
      I have been using eBay since 2005 with 100% positive feedback.
       
       








    • By OzJustin
      Item Condition: Very good working condition Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available. Suburb or Town: Springwood State: QLD Payment Method: Cash on Pickup Reason for selling: No longer required Further information:
      Selling my Anthem MRX 300 AV Receiver
       
      This is an amazing 7 channel receiver for movies and music and puts previous Yamaha, Onkyo etc receivers I've had to shame. The inbuilt amplifier is far more powerful than the specs would suggest and the Anthem Room Correction (ARC) really improves the sound. It also has 7 channel pre-outs so can be used with separate power amplifiers if desired.
       
      The unit is in very good working condition.
       
      Included is the complete kit comprising of the main unit and power cable, Anthem primary remote and zone 2 remote, AM/FM antennas, ARC kit (including calibration microphone, tripod and cables).
       
      Also included is a Tripp-Lite Keyspan USA-19HS USB Serial Adapter. This allows you to connect the unit to modern PC's via USB rather than the older style serial cable that most modern PC's no longer have. Most of the MRX x00 series for sale do not include this adapter. They are about $80 each.
      https://www.tripplite.com/keyspan-high-speed-usb-to-serial-adapter~USA19HS
       
      Note my price is firm. This is a fantastic receiver and I will use it elsewhere in the house if it doesn't sell.
       
      Specifications:
      https://anthemav.com/products-archived/type=av-receiver/model=mrx-300/page=overview
      Specs
      Audio Decoding:
      DOLBY: TrueHD, Digital 5.1, EX, Pro Logic IIz, Volume, Virtual Speaker
      DTS: DTS-HD Master Audio, DTS, ES, 96/24, Neo:6
      OTHER: AnthemLogic-Music, AnthemLogic-Cinema
      3D: Yes
      THX Certification: No
      Number of Amp Channels: 7
      Rated Power (watts per channel): 80 into 8 ohms, 2 channels driven; 60 into 8 ohms, 5 channels driven
      Specified Frequency Response: 20 Hz to 20 kHz (+0/–0.25 dB)
      Video Processing: Genesis Torino
      Auto Setup/Room EQ: Anthem Room Correction
      Dimensions (W x H x D, inches): 17.25 x 6.5 x 15.25
      Weight (pounds): 33.4
       
      Connections
      Inputs: Video: HDMI 1.4a (4), component video (3), composite video (4)
      Audio: Coaxial digital (2), optical digital (3), stereo analog (7), 1/4-inch headphone
      Additional: AM (1), FM (1), IR (1)
      Accessory: Anthem dock (1)
      Outputs: Video: HDMI 1.4a (1), component video (1), composite video (3)
      Audio: Coaxial digital (1), optical digital (1), stereo analog (3), 7.1-channel preamp (1)
      Additional: RS-232 (1), 12-volt trigger (1), IR (2)
       
      Photos:

       

       

       

       

       

       

       
       
       



×
×
  • Create New...