Jump to content

yannakout

High end bookshelf advice

Recommended Posts

Hi all, I am currently investigating stand mount speakers.
I have listened to:
Krix esoterix altum
Dynaudio (multiple pairs) special 40 etc etc
PMC 25.22
Qaccoustics c300
totem signature
preference order (1st Krix esoterix, 2nd PMC, 3rd tie Qaccoustic + totem, 4th dynaudio)

Want to listen to:
Buchardt s400
ATC SCM19
Harbeth 30.1
+ any others people may recommend 

I have a budget ceiling of $5000 and the Krix are well above this unfortunately. 
If anyone has any insight or recommendations that could be awesome, or even if you're in Sydney and friendly enough to allow me to audition.

I am not a bass head (dont listen to EDM or HIpHop) More into natural sounding timbre, great sounding vocals and imaging (sucker for a sweat midrange). 
I also don't want the speaker to sound (small). Qaccoustics really excelled here, sounded like a large floor stander.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whilst above your budget I 'd also recommend having a listening to the B&W 805's and Focal 1008be. They can be sourced second hand within your price range when they come up.

Both are terrific speakers with their own set of pro's and cons.

For vocals and midrange sweetness, I'd plump for the Focal's. They can certainly sound big too.

But that's just my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, dirktoggler said:

Whilst above your budget I 'd also recommend having a listening to the B&W 805's and Focal 1008be. They can be sourced second hand within your price range when they come up.

Both are terrific speakers with their own set of pro's and cons.

For vocals and midrange sweetness, I'd plump for the Focal's. They can certainly sound big too.

But that's just my opinion.

thankyou I will have to give them both a listen :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


The Contrast Lens or Magic are in your ball park.

I haven’t heard those two exact models but the Soul and smaller model gave very good impressions at the recent Hifi show in Melbourne with the sort of sound signature you are after. 
Check the Room  1202 thread on here. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


4 hours ago, jakeyb77 said:

The Contrast Lens or Magic are in your ball park.

I haven’t heard those two exact models but the Soul and smaller model gave very good impressions at the recent Hifi show in Melbourne with the sort of sound signature you are after. 
Check the Room  1202 thread on here. 

They have got into contact with me, look forward to hearing them

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Osborn EOS reference elite are in your price range. I listened to the epitome range and the vocals and midrange blew my Xt8f’s out of the water and I believe they have the same drivers in the EOS. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have much to add here other than I am currently putting money aside for a similar goal, and would be curious to hear your impressions of the Krix, and why they currently top your list.

 

Oh, actually, ProAc Response D2s might be worth considering. I was impressed by their scale and tone when I heard them last. They definitely don't sound small. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You might want to check out Cabasse. Their concentric drivers allow their mid range bookshelf speakers to be 3-way. They don't seem popular in Australia, and so you can get them secondhand at really good prices. They are also pretty efficient so they allow for a wide range of pairings with tube amps which might get you the sound you are looking for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


8 hours ago, twofires said:

I don't have much to add here other than I am currently putting money aside for a similar goal, and would be curious to hear your impressions of the Krix, and why they currently top your list.

 

Oh, actually, ProAc Response D2s might be worth considering. I was impressed by their scale and tone when I heard them last. They definitely don't sound small. 

It just was the natural sound and airiness of them. It’s one of those things where you just stop and enjoy the music.

i night have to put the Hulgich in the top spot though, heard them yesterday and they were beautiful 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, yannakout said:

It just was the natural sound and airiness of them. It’s one of those things where you just stop and enjoy the music.

i night have to put the Hulgich in the top spot though, heard them yesterday and they were beautiful 

Nice. While our music tastes differ, airiness is certainly a quality I appreciate in a speaker - one completely lacking from what I have presently. 

 

Which model of Hulgich did you hear? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
35 minutes ago, twofires said:

Nice. While our music tastes differ, airiness is certainly a quality I appreciate in a speaker - one completely lacking from what I have presently. 

 

Which model of Hulgich did you hear? 

I heard the Nina, I think the Serenade might be my go to as it’s less expensive but still is Sid to have a similar sound profile, not being quite as good tho

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest to think about speakers and amp as a combo. If you want to focus on vocals then some tube integrated $5000+ might be a good option. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Bryston MiniT 3 way bookshelves on sale at Addicted To Audio RRP $6700.00 sale price $3000.00. These are very large bookshelves and weigh in at 19kg each. These provide an excellent soundstage in width depth instrument positioning and vocal localisation. Good power required as they are 85db and 4 ohm. These go low for bookshelves, they have very chunky 8" bass drivers. I am extremely happy with mine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To throw in yet another option, whilst I have not heard them, I have been told the Triangle Signature Theata speakers are comparable to the Focal 1008be's.

There is a demo pair on sale at Shelby's for $2800.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Opera Callas certainly do not sound small - they are on the larger side of bookshelf speakers however:

WWW.APOLLOHIFI.COM.AU

<p>The new Callas speakers use techniques and components that represent the state of the art in electroacoustic, starting from the...

 

They sounded great when demo'd against the Audio Physic floorstander.  The Audio Phsyic sounded boxy and small in comparison.  May have been a sales strategy :-).

 

I can wholeheartedly recommend the Buchardt S400.  I am no bass head either, but it is incredible how much the low end completes the music experience.  The bass is not prominent, but is there when needed.  It is the largest sounding bookshelf I have owned and it puts out a wall of sound.  It does take a lot of hours to break in however and needs careful placement - so if you do buy it, break it in as it sounds compressed out of the box.  

 

Have fun in your search!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Spukee said:

The Opera Callas certainly do not sound small - they are on the larger side of bookshelf speakers however:

WWW.APOLLOHIFI.COM.AU

<p>The new Callas speakers use techniques and components that represent the state of the art in electroacoustic, starting from the...

 

They sounded great when demo'd against the Audio Physic floorstander.  The Audio Phsyic sounded boxy and small in comparison.  May have been a sales strategy :-).

 

I can wholeheartedly recommend the Buchardt S400.  I am no bass head either, but it is incredible how much the low end completes the music experience.  The bass is not prominent, but is there when needed.  It is the largest sounding bookshelf I have owned and it puts out a wall of sound.  It does take a lot of hours to break in however and needs careful placement - so if you do buy it, break it in as it sounds compressed out of the box.  

 

Have fun in your search!

 

Thanks mate ill check it out!
Have you heard the ATC, ProAc, Hulgich, PMC or ?
I kind of want a calibration for the S400 against the likes of those guys

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not direct comparison, but from recollection only and different models.

PMC TB2i, as natural sounding, but S400 sounds much larger and punchier.

Proac 1SC, S400 timbre not as good and treble not as airy, but better in all other respects.

Proac D2, only had limited time with this. D2 sounds thinner and does not have as much weight to mid range. Bottom end tight but not as punchy.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

More into natural sounding timbre, great sounding vocals and imaging (sucker for a sweat midrange). 

 

Given your music taste I would steer you towards the Harbeth, without a doubt.  I would also point you towards the C7 rather than to he 30.1. Perfect for timber, vocals and mid range. 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Xavian Perla Exlusiva if you what natural timbre, vocals to die for and great imaging.

I have a pair and find them fantastic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Audionerd
      Item: Latest Version ATC SCM11 Version 2 Bookshelf Speakers
      Location: Melbourne
      Price: Reduced from $1850 to $1550. RRP was $2999 when I bought them. Donation to SNA on sale
      Item Condition: Excellent
      Reason for selling: Need funds
      Payment Method: Cash, Bank Transfer or Paypal
      Extra Info: While the reputation of ATC needs no explanation, the SCM11s are often regarded as the sweet spot of their current range, with substantial uncoloured bass from a moderately sized enclosure at considerable savings over the larger bookshelf SCM19. Typical ATC accuracy and information retrieval highlights some of the reasons why they are commonly used by British reviewers as a reference, as well as in professional studios.
      This particular pair is as good an example as one can expect from standmount speakers, perfect in every way apart from minor underside scratching from sitting on stands. They come in black ash with original carton, magnetic grilles, manual and all paperwork. Safe postage at buyer's expense is available. Discover what all the fuss is about at a bargain price!
      If these don't sell I'll be listing my SCM7s as well.
       
      Photos: Advertisements without photos of the actual item will not be approved.
       
       







    • By engineer
      Item: PMC Twenty5.26 speakers
      Location: SYDNEY
      Price: $8990
      Item Condition: BRAND NEW - UNOPENED / SEALED BOX
      Reason for selling: RAISING FUNDS FOR UPGRADE
      Payment Method: Pickup - Cash, Paypal, COD Only
      Extra Info:
       
      PMC Twenty5.26 in best finish - Walnut.
       
      BRAND NEW  - UNOPENED / SEALED BOXES.
       
      PRICED TO SELL! (RRP $14990)
       
      These speakers are well known in the audiophile arena on how special they are. They have an amazing open soundstage and are second to none in terms of transparency, pace, imaging and dynamics. They have an incredible ability that tells you so much about the music and sound so open and right.
       
      PMCs 3 ways speaker designs are definitely are major and mammoth step up from there 2 way designs. This speaker is a true representation of the PMC house sound.
       
      Selling due to upgrade bug (as I have also convinced my partner)
       
      Can arrange pickup, drop off locally in Sydney or can post Australia Wide (at buyers cost).
       
      Purchased from Lifestyle Store.
       
      Any queries please feel free to contact me.



    • By engineer
      Item: PMC Twenty5.26 speakers
      Location: SYDNEY
      Price: $8990
      Item Condition: BRAND NEW - UNOPENED / SEALED BOX
      Reason for selling: RAISING FUNDS FOR UPGRADE
      Payment Method: Pickup - Cash, Paypal, COD Only
      Extra Info:
       
       
      PMC Twenty5.26 in best finish - Walnut.
       
      BRAND NEW  - UNOPENED / SEALED BOXES.
       
      PRICED TO SELL! (RRP $14990)
       
      Firstly, I love these speakers. When I first heard them, I totally fell in love. They have an amazing open soundstage and are second to none in terms of transparency, pace, imaging and dynamics. They have an incredible ability that tells you so much about the music. Hence the reason why this model is so very well known in the audiophile community.
       
      The upgrade bug has now totally hit me and now have the opportunity to upgrade. I have also kinda convinced my partner so need to sell before she changes her mind)
       
      Can arrange pickup, drop off locally in Sydney or can post Australia Wide (at buyers cost).
       
      Purchased from Lifestyle Store.
       
      Any queries please feel free to contact me.
       
      Photos:
       




    • By Bikkitz
      Item: PMC Twenty.22 Walnut Speakers
      Location: Brisbane
      Price: $1850
      Item Condition: Very good
      Reason for selling: Upgraded to newer model
      Payment Method: Pickup - Cash, Paypal
      Extra Info: PMC Twenty.22 speakers in walnut finish. I am the second owner, selling as I've purchased a pair of Twenty5.22s in oak.
       
      A main reason for changing was aesthetic as neither my wife or I liked the Walnut finish (which doesn't match with anything else we have). Before deciding to purchase Twenty5.22 I auditioned a number of other speakers at home including Monitor Audio Silver 300s and Gold 100s. Both of these were priced above $3000 and in my opinion were not in the same class as the PMC Twenty.22 (which admittedly retailed for approx $4500 when new). You likely won't get a comparable or better speaker new for less than $4000.
       
      If it wasn't for the walnut finish, I'd have likely kept these speakers for a long time. They have a high sensitivity and are easy to drive however I've read they improve with high power output amps. I ran them on a Marantz KI Pearl Lite and was very happy with their sound.
       
      Full specs available on the PMC website: https://pmc-speakers.com/products/archive/archive/twenty22
       
      The speakers have been very well looked after apart from a small scratch on the underside of one of the speakers as shown in the pictures. For a time they were placed directly on our entertainment cabinet (before I purchased stands) - to stop the cabinet and the speakers vibrating I attached small adhesive pads to the underside of the speakers. These can be removed if necessary, however I've left them on as they may be useful to the next buyer.
       
      Supplied in original box and packaging. Can post with Australia Post, happy to provide a quote on request.
       
      Photos:

       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
       





×
×
  • Create New...