Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  
Doomguy

When to return / request a refund, or just take the hit on a bad record?

Recommended Posts

I recently bought a new record on eBay that has a fair bit of surface noise and a repeated click across the majority of side A. I gave it a glue clean to no avail, it sounds identical, so it's fair to say that I'm very dissatisfied with it; particularly since the comments on discogs about this pressing were quite positive, a couple of people specifically mentioning it as being low noise. The thing is, it would pass as NM to a visual inspection, but I wouldn't feel confident grading it anything higher than VG in listening. Do I contact my eBay seller for a refund or replacement? I do buy a lot of CDs and records from them and this is the first time I think I've been dissatisfied with what I've received. Do I chase it up with the label instead, seeing as it's not really the seller's fault? Paying $36 for a new record only for it to sound crap isn't right. My only reservation is I don't have a way of demonstrating it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Contact the seller.

 

If you're a regular customer he will probably want to keep you. Explain the situation in a friendly manner and see where that takes you.

 

Not doing anything is not going to bring any improvement.

 

Cheers,

 

Alberto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most definitely ask for a refund. 

 

If necessary you could take a video of it playing using your phone? 

 

If they ask for it to be sent back then they will easily be able to hear the faults. So don't worry about being able to prove the faults. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went through this. Seller wouldnt reply.
Ebay refunded purchase price plus return postage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Hi,

 

Ask for a refund / another record, as others have said, if you are a regular customer then they will want to keep your service.

 

JJ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hardly the fault of the seller that the "new" record" sounds like crap.  I'd put it down to experience.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guys, I'm gonna contact the seller. My only concern is that from my experience sellers prefer to send a replacement rather than give refunds, and I'm not sure how much I trust this pressing now. Are 'duds' of otherwise good pressings common? I wonder what my chances of getting a better one would be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many sellers will grade on a visual inspection.  You can't count on them being able to hear the flaw, because they may not have a turntable/many not have a good turntable/may not have discriminating ears to be able to or want to hear the defect. 

 

I would say contact the seller, you may get a good outcome.  But you might also be prepared to take the hit if this doesn't go well. 

 

What's the disk - other people here may have experience with it and be able to give an opinion of the quality. 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


7 hours ago, soundfan said:

Hardly the fault of the seller that the "new" record" sounds like crap.  I'd put it down to experience.

An avoidable bad experience. True, it isn't the sellers fault but it isn't the buyers either. Spending good money should yield a good product. Besides, the seller should be getting a refund from the supplier anyway, so refunding the buyer shouldn't be a problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, audiofeline said:

Many sellers will grade on a visual inspection.  You can't count on them being able to hear the flaw, because they may not have a turntable/many not have a good turntable/may not have discriminating ears to be able to or want to hear the defect. 

 

I would say contact the seller, you may get a good outcome.  But you might also be prepared to take the hit if this doesn't go well. 

 

What's the disk - other people here may have experience with it and be able to give an opinion of the quality. 

 

 

It's Enter the Wu-Tang (36  Chambers) which has a ton of different pressings around, so fairly unlikely anybody here has specific experience with this one. I bought the 2018 yellow pressing on the advice of the favourable discogs comments. It's the first time I've ever bought coloured vinyl over black and I'd say it's hands down the worst sounding new record I've bought. Won't be making the same mistake again any time soon.

9 hours ago, stevoz said:

An avoidable bad experience. True, it isn't the sellers fault but it isn't the buyers either. Spending good money should yield a good product. Besides, the seller should be getting a refund from the supplier anyway, so refunding the buyer shouldn't be a problem.

I should also note that the seller is a business who ships a lot of stuff (500K+ feedback), they're not a little guy selling records out of their lounge-room. If they don't take it up with their supplier I wouldn't be surprised if they just eat it and move on.

Edited by Doomguy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't think about it too long. There is a limited time to complain. I took a while getting back re a CD with a visible piece of surface coating missing (causing dropout in the middle of the disc). The vendor has not replied to messages and the complaint/mediation period is no longer available.

It was a cheaper used disc, but the description was wrong, or at least misleading. That's what happens to people who procrastinate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks guys, I'm gonna contact the seller. My only concern is that from my experience sellers prefer to send a replacement rather than give refunds, and I'm not sure how much I trust this pressing now. Are 'duds' of otherwise good pressings common? I wonder what my chances of getting a better one would be.

 

The truth is there’s good sellers and there’s bad sellers. You could only ask and hope you get a good one to send you refund without a problem. Some would ask you to send the record back, some will pay for return postage some need you to pay for it. Some would refund and let you keep the record. So it all depends on your luck.

 

Like someone have said before, if you do nothing then nothing is going to happen. But if you try then something good might happen, but do prepare for a bad experience. I wish you good luck. [emoji16]

 

I have found new records’ quality hit and miss. I have experienced in the same pressing, exchange a dude one for an absolutely quiet one, even a muddy sounding one to a much clearer one! Also like you, a “supposedly” quiet pressing turned out to be a noise fest.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


@Doomguy I hope you have follow up and requested a full refund.....you deserve one. I always do (in a nice way, getting angry never helps) and if the seller requests the record returned, I tell them they will pay for return postage.

 

You should never have to pay to return it for a mistake that is not your fault. If I purchased through ebay, I usually tell the seller that I haven't gone through ebay yet, preferring to let them come up with a suitable solution. That solution is usually a full refund and to keep the record. Those sellers will get my return business and positive feedback. If they persist with what I consider is an unfair outcome, they get blacklisted and I get onto ebay to force a fair outcome, which they usually do.....

This approach has seen me get probably a 90% full refund rate while keeping the record. Approx. 5%, full refund after returning record at their expense and approx. 5% 'take the hit' and blacklist the seller.

 

You do have rights and should never be left 'out of pocket'.👍

 

 

Edited by stevoz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I sent them a polite message about it last night clearly explaining the issue and that I don't want them to send a replacement as I just don't trust this pressing now, and that I've always been very satisfied when buying from them in the past etc. Regardless of whether I get a refund or not I'm probably just going to buy the CD and be happy with that as this is not an album that has a particularly good reputation on vinyl in general. If they ever do a good double LP reissue I'll look into that. Though, I suppose finding a used copy that somebody could verify the SQ of is also an option.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Due to the seller's poor packing, I once received a box set which was torn and battered. I requested another box set, correctly packed, and asked them to pay the return postage for the damaged box set. Instead, they offered a few dollars of credit (I think it represented about 5% of the value of the box set). I declined, and they refunded the sale in full and didn't ask for the goods to be returned. Moral of the story, stick to your guns, as you have the right to expect the product and condition you paid for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Goatboy said:

Due to the seller's poor packing, I once received a box set which was torn and battered. I requested another box set, correctly packed, and asked them to pay the return postage for the damaged box set. Instead, they offered a few dollars of credit (I think it represented about 5% of the value of the box set). I declined, and they refunded the sale in full and didn't ask for the goods to be returned. Moral of the story, stick to your guns, as you have the right to expect the product and condition you paid for.

If a record was damaged due to insufficient packaging / packing I have no reservation about asking for discounts or replacements.  I've also taken note which sellers use what type of mailers. I got into vinyl 3 years ago and in my experience so far the mailers that have extra width, to act as 'crumple zones' for the corners, dramatically increase the chance that my record will actually arrive in mint condition. Of course, the heavier the record the more important it is, so if I'm buying a single 140g LP, if it's a particularly good deal from a seller that uses more so-so mailers then I can take that risk. However, if I'm buying a double 180g gatefold or something, a high quality mailer is absolutely required and I'll gladly spend a few dollars more if needed to get it from somewhere that packages their records properly. 

Removing the records from the sleeve is another layer on top entirely, though I haven't noticed as strong of a correlation there so far. I think it's mostly about the mailer and the luck of the draw as to whether or not anyone in the postal service decides to use your valuable package as a makeshift frisbee.

Edited by Doomguy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


I’ve a few records received in the mail which have cover damage. Can only assume this is due to the accelerating vinyl puncturing the cardboard as it’s launched as a frisbee by the courier. This is a difficult one from the seller’s POV as they need to open mint records to prevent this. Almost every seller I’ve encountered separate the vinyl and cover for 2nd hand records though. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
54 minutes ago, Goatboy said:

Almost every seller I’ve encountered separate the vinyl and cover for 2nd hand records though. 

You haven't spent much time on Discogs, have you....  :devil:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Muon N'

......................

Edited by Muon N'

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, candyflip said:

You haven't spent much time on Discogs, have you....  :devil:

Lol. I must be lucky !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On ‎1‎/‎06‎/‎2019 at 12:29 PM, Doomguy said:

I recently bought a new record on eBay that has a fair bit of surface noise and a repeated click across the majority of side A. I gave it a glue clean to no avail, it sounds identical, so it's fair to say that I'm very dissatisfied with it; particularly since the comments on discogs about this pressing were quite positive, a couple of people specifically mentioning it as being low noise. The thing is, it would pass as NM to a visual inspection, but I wouldn't feel confident grading it anything higher than VG in listening. Do I contact my eBay seller for a refund or replacement? I do buy a lot of CDs and records from them and this is the first time I think I've been dissatisfied with what I've received. Do I chase it up with the label instead, seeing as it's not really the seller's fault? Paying $36 for a new record only for it to sound crap isn't right. My only reservation is I don't have a way of demonstrating it.

you could open up a discussion, and see what they say as a minimum.  The condition of the Album (IMO) had nothing to do with packaging, nor damage during transit. So, i'm inclined to say its the pressing or bad inners (those f'ing paper inners kill me).  However, if the seller moves a lot of albums, they may get a credit for the faulty album and give you an exchange/refund.

 

I had a similar thing recently with Juno. Blue Note 75Th Anniversary titles are mostly paper inners (maybe some exceptions..). Lee Morgan - Lee Way was one that arrived and upon first play after a RCM clean was still very noisy. After an Ultra sonic clean, still noisy.  The paper inners had damaged it beyond being restored.

 

Not the fault of Juno, more so Blue Note quality and use of way too cheap inners.  I sent them some feedback, I didn't ask for a replacement - however was sent one. I simply wanted them to feedback to BN that they need to stop damaging their products with cheap Inners and use poly ones.

 

Treat the seller how you'd like to be treated, it can go along way with a reputable seller / retail outlet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, scuzzii said:

 i'm inclined to say its the pressing or bad inners (those f'ing paper inners kill me). 

Definitely the former as it came in a poly-lined paper sleeve. I agree that paper inner sleeves suck, but I don't think I've ever really experienced them to do anything worse than get a few paper shards over the record or maybe some light surface scuffing. I don't see how they could substantially harm the grooves themselves, especially to this degree. Some of the nicer pressings in my collection came in paper sleeves, I just replace them straight away and don't worry too much about it. Kinda blows my mind that there are places that actually sell paper sleeves though, I can't comprehend why you would ever buy them on purpose. Maybe for a sworn enemy or something.

Edited by Doomguy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

there is someone, somewhere doing the Dr Evil laugh as people open an Album and see a paper inner...…..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, scuzzii said:

there is someone, somewhere doing the Dr Evil laugh as people open an Album and see a paper inner...…..

Probably MoFi and anyone else whose inner sleeves end up running a dollar each.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, scuzzii said:

Not the fault of Juno, more so Blue Note quality and use of way too cheap inners.  I sent them some feedback, I didn't ask for a replacement - however was sent one. I simply wanted them to feedback to BN that they need to stop damaging their products with cheap Inners and use poly ones.

 

Treat the seller how you'd like to be treated, it can go along way with a reputable seller / retail outlet.

Juno are excellent.

 

Great customer service, fast replies and always friendly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Classifieds Statistics


    Currently Active Ads

    Total Sales (Since 2018)

    Total Sales Value (Last 14 Days)

    Total Ads Value (Since March 2020)
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By merro
      Item: Various Vinyl Classical Organ
      Price Range: Free
      Item Condition: Used 26 classical organ titles, ive taken a picture of the spines to indicate what's there, will not separate
       
      Pickup from Jervis Bay or Sylvania NSW
       
       

    • By Warren M.
      Item Condition: Most records UNPLAYED MINT. Others NM played once or twice on audiophile system. Boxes in exceptional condition for age VG+. Sleeves and booklets in NM condition. Shipping Options: Pickup available and you can audition.,Shipping is available at agreed cost. Suburb or Town: Bronte (Sydney Eastern Suburbs) State: New South Wales Payment Method: Paypal, EFT, Cash on pickup Reason for selling: Financial stress Further information: 

      This Georg Solti / Vienna Philharmonic Wagner Ring performance/recording is still regarded by many as the best on record, and no subsequent reissue even gets close to equalling these spectacularly good limited edition pressings by Decca UK.
       
      Released in 1970 as a limited special edition. 22 records in 5 boxes enclosed in a uniquely designed outer slipcase.
       
      At the time it was the highest priced record set on the market and sold out soon after release! I recall "Mr Rowe Street" (Sydney's most iconic classical record store owner) pointing to the "last unsold copy in Australia" and the following week it was gone.

      The boxes are now 50 years old and inevitably the outer cover and box spines have sustained minor degradation over that time, but remain in beautiful condition overall. I've conservatively classed them as VG+.

      Everything else ranges from NM to MINT condition!!! Most of the vinyl has NEVER been played.

      Each box has full libretto in German and English along with detailed synopsis of each opera as well as technical recording details.
       
      The full set weighs just under 12 kg before packing it up protectively for shipping, so allow at least 13 kg shipping weight. Note that I have access to much better insured interstate shipping rates than Australia Post. For instance estimate for fast door-to-door delivery to inner Melbourne OR even inner Perth suburbs from Sydney, including insurance, would be under $30! 

      There is a similar-condition set (maybe not quite as good) on eBay for UK£330 (about AU$600) plus shipping (+$200 to Australia) plus GST.
       
      PRICE IS NEGOTIABLE
       
      Additional information from Discogs
      Wagner's Der Ring Des Nibelungen 22 LP Decca Box Set Incredible 1970 UK TWENTY TWO stereo LP boxed set of the complete edition of Richard Wagner's four part opera, 'Der Ring des Nibelungen', also known as 'The Ring Cycle' featuring the four operas 'Das Rheingold','Die Walkure', 'Siegfried' and 'Gotterdammerung'.

      There is also a unique three record introduction to 'The Ring' set narrated by Deryck Cooke featuring excerpts from the four operas.

      Each opera is in its own separate wooden ended partition with full size libretto booklets containing synopsis & full transcription for the operas.
      The performance is THE classic version by the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Georg Solti,
       a powerful orchestral drama, phenomenal performance and superb sound.

      The whole ensemble is enclosed in a very weighty carved wooden box with gilded front panel.

      Details of Records:

      DER RING DES NIBELUNGEN

      * Guide & Introduction to "Der Ring des Nibelungen" by Deryck Cooke
      * Recording year: 1968
      * Record number: ZAL 8422-7
      * Number of LP’s: THREE
      * Orchestra: Introduction By (Sir) Georg Solti

      DAS RHIENGOLD

      * Recording year: 1958
      * Record number: ZAL 4260-5
      * Number of LP’s: THREE
      * Orchestra: Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra & Vienna State Opera Chorus, conducted by (Sir) Georg Solti.
      * Cast: Jean Madeira, Set Svanholm, George London, Kirsten Flagstad. Claire Watson, Gustav Neidlinger, Kurt Böhme, Eberhard Wächter, Walter Kreppel

      DIE WALKÜRE

      * Recording year: 1966
      * Record number: ZAL 7131 – 7140
      * Number of LP’s: FIVE
      * Orchestra: Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra & Vienna State Opera Chorus, conducted by (Sir) Georg Solti.
      * Cast: Gottlob Frick, Regine Crespin, James King, Brigit Nilsson, Christa Ludwig

      SIEGFRIED

      * Recording year: 1963
      * Record number: ZAL 5742-52
      * Number of LP’s: FIVE
      * Orchestra: Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra & Vienna State Opera Chorus, conducted by (Sir) Georg Solti.
      * Cast: Wolfgang Windgassen, Brigit Nilsson, Hans Hotter, Gerhard Stolze, Gustav Neidlinger, Kurt Bohme, Marga Hoffgen

      GÖTTERDÄMMERUNG

      * Recording year: 1965
      * Record number: ZAL 6673-6684
      * Number of LP’s: SIX
      * Orchestra: Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra & Vienna State Opera Chorus, conducted by (Sir) Georg Solti
      * Cast: Briget Nilsson, Wolfgang Windgassen, Gustav Neidlinger, Gottlob Frick, Claire Watson Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, Christa Ludwig, Lucia Popp, Gwyneth Jones, Maureen Guy, Helen Watts, Grace Hoffman, Anita Välkki
      Photos: 

       

       

       

       

    • By MTsoul
      Hey all, 
       
      I'm heading down to the Bowral/Mittagong/Moss Vale area for the long weekend and was wondering if anyone knew of any good places to look for vinyl?
    • By candyflip
      Item Condition: Sealed and NEW Shipping Options: Shipping is included in price. Suburb or Town: Melbourne State: Victoria Payment Method: Paypal, EFT Reason for selling: latest finds Price and item conditions ...as specified below 
      Delivery Methods:  NO PICKUPS SORRY - mail only.
      Bank transfers, or PayPal (Friends & Family only, no notes) are both welcome.
       
      STUFF YOU NEED TO KNOW:
              Once all sold (or near to), a donation to SNA of 5% of items total will follow.
              Any titles here get brand new inner and/or outer quality Blake sleeves as needed before shipping.
              I try and ship 3-4 days a week.

      THE SMALL PRINT:
             I fully guarantee everything I offer  - if you don't like any item for whatever reason, return it at my expense for a full refund, no questions asked (verified 30 day+ active Forum members only thanks)..
             Original contents are stored inside the cover.
      I try to ship all records themselves outside the cover, so any postal damage is minimised.
             I use mostly s/hand pre-made cardboard mailers for all orders, and these virtually guarantee safe arrival of your record (they are also MUCH faster to pack).
             Combined postage to anywhere in Australia at cost (or close enough) and is EXTRA (ie. not included in prices). 
            ABSOLUTELY NO LOCAL PICKUPS - don't ask - it's not going to happen.
      Complain to me loudly if anything goes wrong (although it barely ever does) - and it'll be fixed, in your favour. 
       
       Please post in this thread  to reserve your item(s).
       
      __________________________________
       
      The Rat Pack – Live At The Sands – 2LP Limited reissue in gatefold - BRAND NEW & SEALED.
      2014 rmastered set, originally recorded live at The Sands Hotel, Las Vegas, Nevada on September 7, 1963. Includes liner notes by Bill Zehme. Digitally remastered by Lee Herschberg. Pressed in the Netherlands and sounds fantastic.
      For those whose favourite part of the legendary Sinatra/Count Basie LIVE AT THE SANDS album was Frank's lengthy comedic monologue, THE RAT PACK: LIVE AT THE SANDS will arrive like manna from hipster's heaven. The disc features an entire performance by the storied "rat pack" of the Chairman and his musical pals Dean Martin and Sammy Davis, Jr., but most of the show is given over to shtick and banter. Fittingly, Sinatra gets the most straight-ahead musical time with a brace of sterling ballads whose appearance should delight hardcore fans. Fortunately, the humorous barbs passed around the stage for the bulk of the performance are extremely sharp and funny (if politically incorrect in the extreme). Taken as a comedy album with some stirring musical moments, this disc is a gem for those who revere the Rat Pack, as they are captured at the peak of their powers and popularity, exuding hipness from every pore. LIVE AT THE SANDS is a bona fide cultural artefact documenting one generation's apex of cool.    $35

       

      Alan Parsons Project – I Robot – 2LP LEGACY 2013 release 35th Anniversary Edition - BRAND NEW & SEALED.
      MOV pressing in a gatefold sleeve. Including an 8 page booklet with rare photos & liner notes by Alan Parsons, and 14 bonus tracks on the second disc.
      Lovely double album package.    $45







      Led Zeppelin - How The West Was Won (SUPER DELUXE EDITION) – 4LP, 3CD, DVD and Book – 2018 EU pressed Box Set. BRAND NEW & SEALED.
      'How The West Was Won' highlights the best performances from Led Zeppelin’s legendary concerts at the Los Angeles Forum and Long Beach Arena on June 25 and 27, 1972. Standouts include a 25-plus minute version of 'Dazed And Confused' and a 21-minute medley based around 'Whole Lotta Love'. The performances also capture the band introducing songs from its then-unreleased album 'Houses Of The Holy', which would be released nine months later. The Super Deluxe Boxed Set contains: Remastered audio on three CDs and four 180-gram vinyl LPs. DVD of the album in Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround and PCM Stereo, plus photo gallery. High-def download card of all stereo audio content at 96kHz/24 bit. A 52 page book filled with rare and previously unpublished photos of the band at each of the concert locations, plus memorabilia and ephemera. High-quality print of the original album cover, the first 30,000 of which will be individually numbered.
      Goes for anywhere from $230-$245 online anywhere you care to check.   
      How's half that?      $125
      (ALL GONE)
        

        


      My latest YouTube videos are centred around spinning the unusual, coloured, MOFI, Half Speeds, Aussie, rare and just plain interesting vinyl of classic rock tracks including Meat Loaf, Pink Floyd, TOOL and the Blade Runner OST - have a look!

      Here's the newest one : YouTube
    • By Masseey
      Thinking of adding Vinyl to my digital stereo listening. 
       
      What will be the very best setup to step into 
       
      Rega or ProJet or Music hall for the first turntable 
       
      Cart?
       
      Budget < 1000$ brand new

×
×
  • Create New...