Jump to content

Restoration advice C1924 Thorens “Picnic” record player and Edison C1905 Cyliner player


Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

 

I have fortunately just acquired a C1924 Thorens “Picnic” portable record player and Edison cylinder player that I’d like to restore.

 

I have done some antique restoration in the past, so I can probably handle the wooden components and possibly the horn, however the mechanical components, whilst incredibly simple are possibly beyond my capabilities - in particular the Thorens main spring has broken and apart from a watchmaker, I’m not sure where to start?

 

The Edison works perfectly, but lacks a support arm and adapter sleeve for the horn.

 

Any advice would be welcome.

 

Thanks,

 

Malcolm

 

IMG_3034.thumb.JPG.39796bce5f6af98ff1489119be58e8f8.JPG

 

IMG_5702.thumb.JPG.81b53d7538a16c0b0fefa0631e93b459.JPG

 

IMG_6553.thumb.JPG.60dd806165ba3aebd0b944615677eda3.JPGIMG_6553.thumb.JPG.60dd806165ba3aebd0b944615677eda3.JPG

 

IMG_8077.thumb.JPG.94f86a00c702be394189cfe61afd55c3.JPG

 

IMG_4963.thumb.JPG.40a6464db2dcf99eefeda5375fc28368.JPGIMG_2260.thumb.JPG.7eee77f3494197f49b66d485b1952dcf.JPGIMG_0166.thumb.JPG.a70066469b65bdb803ecb8568b5d0e9d.JPGIMG_4582.thumb.JPG.0e67e2cc4522eb94c486bfbeaedb60bf.JPGIMG_6803.thumb.JPG.c05817e7edee701dcd6a12e4227ccf7c.JPGIMG_7373.thumb.JPG.bce798bfc837019d5a21202ac2aac8c3.JPGIMG_9226.thumb.JPG.2a2c05ad717409ecb30bd13a20dba7e6.JPG

 

 

IMG_4176.JPG

IMG_4614.JPG

Link to post
Share on other sites

What a cool project! Looking forward to seeing this progress.
Springs are an interesting one. I've seen clock springs on eBay. If you have the dimensions on length I'm sure a decent one could be found on the old interwebs.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites




2 minutes ago, eltech said:

I'm fairly sure the white stripes next album will be released on Edison cylinder, so this is good timing.

Can’t wait!

Link to post
Share on other sites
Any ideas on restoration of the horn?

 

It’s got surface rust all over?

 

Thanks,

 

Malcolm

Might be worth trying a couple of things on some test peices first. But Bicarb soda and a little water made into a paste is one that was suggested to me recently. Vinegar would be another. The issue with the vinegar is that you'd need a reasonable quantity and a decent sized container to do at least half at a time. Maybe a combination of both to get right down into the throat. Or does it come apart along the join? Hard to tell with the photo.

The real issue is painting all the way down into the throat to protect it once your done. I've found that the much larger throat sizes I work with (1"-3") can be very difficult to get a good finish. Maybe some form of electrostatic sort painting?

 

What I'm getting at is, be careful not to strip away what little finish it has if it can't be replaced.

Link to post
Share on other sites


13 hours ago, Unsound said:

Any ideas on restoration of the horn?

 

It’s got surface rust all over?

 

Thanks,

 

Malcolm

 

I'm not sure how much you want to spend on it. I suspect sand or walnut shell, or bead blasting should get the rust and old paint off. You might need to treat the surface with something before its sprayed. I'm sure a professional painter will know what to do.

 

If you want to do it yourself, perhaps steel wool followed by wet and dry sandpaper, then rust converter, then spray from a can?

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Unsound said:

Any ideas on restoration of the horn?

It’s got surface rust all over?

Does it need to be restored?  There are different philosophies on restoration.  One is to return it to as-new condition, and I don't have any problems with that if the item is worth the time/money.  Another is to restore it to newish-order, good working condition but not necessarily accurate to it's original form - I personally don't like this approach.

 

The other is to keep the patina of age - it has it's own character which tells the journey of the item.  Restore it to working condition, clean it and make it nice, but don't over-do it. 

 

I love the look it currently has.  So I would fix the wood work, get it in excellent mechanical working condition, clean it up but keep the existing character of the horn and other mechanicals. 

 

 

Edited by audiofeline
Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, audiofeline said:

Does it need to be restored?  There are different philosophies on restoration.  One is to return it to as-new condition, and I don't have any problems with that if the item is worth the time/money.  Another is to restore it to newish-order, good working condition but not necessarily accurate to it's original form - I personally don't like this approach.

 

The other is to keep the patina of age - it has it's own character which tells the journey of the item.  Restore it to working condition, clean it and make it nice, but don't over-do it. 

 

I love the look it currently has.  So I would fix the wood work, get it in excellent mechanical working condition, clean it up but keep the existing character of the horn and other mechanicals. 

 

 

Thanks audio feline,,

 

I’m inclined to agree with the minimal intervention model I think that I’ll clean it up and see how it looks, but the horn is an issue, as if you touch it or brush up against it, you get dirty hands/clothes, which is not conducive to a happy home environment. I also worry about the rust continuing to eat away at it and causing it to eventually break up.

 

Cheers,

 

Malcolm

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites


4 hours ago, Unsound said:

..the horn is an issue,... I also worry about the rust continuing to eat away at it and causing it to eventually break up.

I take your point.  There may be a treatment you can get to halt the rust process.  I know there is a "kill rust" paint, but the tin I inherited from my father is a silver colour paint.  There may be a treatment that is more invisible.  Ask my research team at Google. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I work a bit with Patina finishes on steel, there is a number of ways to halt the rust, basically you need to seal the item to stop oxidation.

 

for the horn I would suggest the following two methods.

 

step one is the same for both methods, cleaning - warm water and sugar soap, lightly sponge clean the horn to remove the dirt and any loose rust, dry with a lint free cloth.

 

dull finish - coat sparingly with pale boiled linseed oil, you will find the oil will feed into the rusted areas and pool on what is left of the paint, wipe dry with a lint free cloth. May need a couple of coats but leave for a day or two in between. 

 

Luster finish - this is what I'd go for, there could be a store brought product but we make our own 

45% natural bees wax

45% pure gum turpentine 

10% sanding sealant (can be deleted) we use it to speed up the drying process 

 

Use a gas cooker outside and melt the wax in an old pot, careful highly flammable.

once liquid, remove from the heat and add the turps and sealer

as it cools it will thicken, if I'm applying to timber I use it fairly hot and thin so it drives deeply into the wood, for steel I let it go a bit thicker and coat with an old brush. It will take a day or so to dry then you can buff it with lambs wool or a lint free cloth. Eventually the turps will evaporate and leave a hard wax that can be buffed shiny for years.

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Powerglide
  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Fantastic Powerglide!

Much appreciated.

I was aware of that method for the wood, but the metal could be a lifesaver!

Cheers

Malcolm

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fantastic Powerglide!

Much appreciated.

I was aware of that method for the wood, but the metal could be a lifesaver!

Cheers

Malcolm

Link to post
Share on other sites

The linseed approach will turn the rust quite dark

 

the wax is the way to go the only trouble you could get into is, if its too thick it won't buff out smoothly, if this happens re heat with a hair dryer or hot air gun to melt the wax and remove some with a cloth 

 

Don't those needles look savage !

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 year later...
13 minutes ago, audiofeline said:

@Unsound Any updates on the restoration, Malcolm?

Now that you remind me:

 

Here are some photos of the finished products - both play well - the Rexanola could probably do with a new spring, but it still works, but runs out of puff quickly (like me)!

 

Before

IMG_0332.thumb.jpeg.9157c31b9da50bea81b3143802e6ba80.jpeg

 

After - handle is now restored and installed

 

IMG_0331.thumb.jpeg.8bb4c4ef2232e9b2e4c750327f72ca24.jpeg

 

Detail

IMG_0338.thumb.jpeg.2f2e56509180847a0fe7790b22190f88.jpeg

 

Rexanola

 

IMG_0323.thumb.jpeg.b5546b560735981aff1545c4ac1c058d.jpeg

  • Like 3
  • Love 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

A wonderful job, you have done very well! 

Looks like you went for the full refinishing of the horn. 

 

Are you pleased with the sound you get from the cylinders?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I sent the horn to Sydney to be redone - I did not have a bath big enough to immerse it in to clean off the crud.

 

The sound is as you would expect - certainly not "HiFi", but interesting to hear the origins of the species.

 

Certainly both are "talking points" in the house and the owner of both was going to dispose of them in the tip, so I think that they have another 100 years in them now (unlike me)!

 

I recon better cables may help 😉.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, bob_m_54 said:

A great job there mate, but I have one question. Why did you spell your name Mslcolm in your profile panel? 🤔

Thanks, fixed!

  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By OTOXO
      Item Condition: New Shipping Options: Pickup available and you can audition. Suburb or Town: Sydney State: New South Wales Payment Method: Cash on Pickup Reason for selling: Further information: Thorens TD 190-2 Turntable as new still in box. Purchased back in 2015 (see photos). Item sold as is. It’s still disassembled if you are interested in buying you are welcome to assemble it on site to make sure its functioning as it should.

      Pickup Leichhardt
       
      Photos:
       




    • By Mr Vintage
      Item Condition: Excellent Shipping Options: Shipping is available at agreed cost. Suburb or Town: Holland Park State: Queensland Payment Method: Reason for selling: Wanted to Buy Further information: 
       
      Hi all, 
       
      I’m interested in buying an SME S3 Tonearm. 

      Feel free to get in touch if you have or know someone looking at selling.
      Its going on a Thorens however, will consider another brand that also works well on a suspended deck.
      With or without Cart is fine.
      Price listed is a guide. Will negotiate upon application. 
      Cheers!
       
      Photos:
       
      PLEASE READ
      If you are advertising multiple items, you must post one bulk price only, or post seperate ads for each item If you include any reference to pricing whatsoever in this section (excluding RRP), your ad will not be approved If you don't include photographs of the actual item being sold, your ad will not be approved
    • By Tax
      Item Condition: Vintage Shipping Options: Pickup available but audition is not available.,Shipping is available at agreed cost. Suburb or Town: NSW 2745 State: New South Wales Payment Method: EFT, Cash on pick up Reason for selling: Can't decide Further information:
       
      PRICED TO SELL
       
      Vintage Thorens TD160 turntable with TP tonearm. Original plinth and wiring. 
       
      This TT has quite a global following. It is a suspended table and can be upgraded (if desired) by adding a new heavier plinth and new tonearm wiring. Some say they prefer this to a Linn. You can decide.
       
      Prefer a local sale but also happy to hand deliver it to the local Pack and Send if you want it shipped interstate. You will need to organise pack and send to box them up for you as I do not have the original boxes.
       
      Photos show condition of this fine vintage TT and form part of the item description. Has some dynamat on the underside of the top plate which you can remove if preferred. It was considered a tweak.
       
      I have not mounted a cartridge on this original TP tonearm as I was using the turntable with a SME3009 tonearm and Audio Technica AT155LC cartridge which are not part of this sale.
       
      You will need to mount your own cartridge.
       
      Priced fairly for a quick hassle free sale. Thanks for looking!

      Photos:
       
       









    • By Yarrum78
      Item Condition: Excellent Original Condition Shipping Options: Pickup available and you can audition. Suburb or Town: Mitchelton State: Queensland Payment Method: Eft or Cash on Pickup Reason for selling: Surplus to my needs The Thorens TD 160 Super was the top end model of the 160 Series. This premium Thorens model was not manufactured in great numbers, in fact there's a business that creates these as reproductions from standard 160's.
        
      For those who don’t know, what made the Super model the Super was a heavier platter, and a 'floating suspension' system. The platter and main bearing are supported on a secondary chassis which is spring-mounted to isolate it not only from the main case and external forces but also from vibrations of the motor. To preserve pickup/platter geometry, the pickup arm board is also mounted directly on to this sub-chassis. It also has internal dampening to benefit sound quality and a base cover. 
       
      This particular TT is unmolested, with perhaps only the plugs replaced. I haven't used it regular for the last 3 years and it probably should be lubricated. A belt is provided and is still supple and should serve you for many years. 
       
      It currently has a Denon103R fitted. I am happy to remove that if you want to save yourself some money. The cart has had less than 100 hours use.

      Some minor imperfections do exist:
      There are some small nicks in the particle board base a long one side, they are not visible from the front. The lid needs a polish, but there are no deep gouges. The hinges need some adjustment to hold the lid in place if opened beyond 90 degrees.   
      Pickup preferred. For serious buyers I can demo the TT connected to a Weston Time Machine and a pair of Zu Audio Omen Bookshelf speakers.
       
      Any questions, please feel free message me.
       
       Photos:
       
       












    • By Sansui77
      Item: Vintage Turntable
      Price Range: Neg
      Item Condition: Used
      Extra Info:
       
      Looking for a vintage turntable project or complete table. I was thinking of a Garrard 401, Thorens etc. Let me know what you have.
       



×
×
  • Create New...