Jump to content

Sean84

Advice for fixed screen for daylight viewing and projector

Recommended Posts

Hi all

 

Just looking for advice / recommendations for fixed screens that perform well in daylight viewing, but also good for night viewing too.
 

Is there a high quality recommendation within a budget <$2k for the screen?

 

And does it need a specific type of projector? Projector budget < $3k.

 

Or to put it better, budget is $5k for projector and screen. 

 

Size of 100 inches (or larger if budget allows).

 

I'm not too fussed on 4K right now, but really good quality full HD 1080 is a must for the projector. 4K is a bonus for future proofing.

 

I don't really know much about either, so I'm happy to get advice from your experiences and knowledge out there.

 

Cheers!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You really need to get light control in your room during daylight hours, or spend megabucks on a specialty daylight screen that may still have issues with hotspots or poor off-axis viewing due to the highly reflective finish used. Start with the room, not the projector or screen.

 

Speaking of room, can't tell whether you need a short, medium or long throw projector without knowing room dimensions, any limits on projector mounting and which wall you're projecting on to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of the expensive daytime screens work quite well.

Even with that, if you cant attenuate light in the roim - image quality will suffer greatly and looked washed out. A 1080i CRT from almost 20 years ago will look better.

I would suggest looking at a 75 inch oled if primarily viewing in daylight. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Quark said:

Speaking of room, can't tell whether you need a short, medium or long throw projector without knowing room dimensions, any limits on projector mounting and which wall you're projecting on to.

 

Thanks Quark! 

 

This isn’t for a dedicated room. It’s for an open space living room with the fixed projector screen to be in there.

 

Seating is ~ 4-5m from the wall and the projector can be an distance less than that (doesn’t need to be above seating position), ceiling mounted.

 

I should add daytime viewing is mostly for sport in full HD - maybe 4K if content moves in that direction over the next 2-3 years.

 

Daytime viewing would never really be for movies.

 

I really want 100 inches minimum if the $5k budget allows.

 

Fixed screen is preferred.

 

Appreciate any advice / recommendations

 

Edited by Sean84

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Moderator

Sean I run a screen in what is a open plan layout that can be closed off it’s surrounded by windows 7 in all around the room and s light filled staircase behind. But with pelmet and block out blinds and doors closing off the room I get pretty Good elimination of light during the day with one more opportunity to improve which been on plan fir years done nothing as happy enough

 

with light if it’s direct on screen it will be a killer. If indirect depending on tolerance you might find fine. With cricket for instance I don’t bother closing off room at rear which opens to dining kitchen abd staircase as light is indirect and be surprised how good

 

if can’t do anything about direct light one of those daylight screens is possible but cost ridiculously is amounts and not without their issues and limitations 

 

projectors have come s long way and as long as don’t go too huge even with decent calibration running at typical suggested  14FL luminesce it will look like a big plasma even with some light in the room. Ie back lighting or indirect light

 

its hard to know what your room looks like without pictures or what efforts needed to get conducive for projection. Without this makes very difficult  fir people to suggest anything bar go to flat screen panel instead

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Al.

 

Definitely will have direct light blocked because I've seen what direct light can do with washing out the picture during day time. Looks horrible.

 

I know those black screens are expensive - are they grey screens a good 'in between' for daylight viewing?

 

The problem with flat screen panel is I've seen sport on 100 inches and anything less now looks bad :-)

 

I guess if I wait 3 years we will probably have a 100 inch flat panel screen within the $5k budget.

 

Still, if anyone can give a recommendation of projector and screen for $5k, happy to look into it.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As Al mentioned, with some curtains and pelmets you should be able to get your room reasonably dark in daylight you'll be good to go with a normal screen up around 120". Don't go too small - what seems large at first will look smaller after a few weeks.

 

If your budget can stretch a little past $5K, contact Rich at Oz Theatre Screens to see what package deal can be done for a JVC X5900 , mount and 120" 16:9 screen. You'll also need cables - I'd suggest the Ruipro cables here if you have a run of over 10m.

 

If your budget is tight Sony HW45 will be on sale here tomorrow at current price less 20% discount using code PCTECH, plus grab a 120" 16:9 screen from Selby Acoustics.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Quark said:

20" 16:9 screen

 

Do grey screens give better daytime performance than white? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Moderator
36 minutes ago, Sean84 said:

Thanks Al.

 

Definitely will have direct light blocked because I've seen what direct light can do with washing out the picture during day time. Looks horrible.

 

I know those black screens are expensive - are they grey screens a good 'in between' for daylight viewing?

 

The problem with flat screen panel is I've seen sport on 100 inches and anything less now looks bad :-)

 

I guess if I wait 3 years we will probably have a 100 inch flat panel screen within the $5k budget.

 

Still, if anyone can give a recommendation of projector and screen for $5k, happy to look into it.

 

THE main problem with grey screens you there and there give away the possibility to do pure whites... I know some will say oh its a touch grey and still look white, but sorry for serious viewing i for one wouldn't want to give up ability to do whites. 

 

below are a couple of shots of the cricket, with my rear doors open, ie some light in the room, indirect 

24825573527_dd7f996943_b.jpg

 

39694114591_108bac69d6_b.jpg

 

though your set up is likely quite different to mine and in my setup have blocked out all direct light. and above is ok for me watching cricket, i wouldn't watch a movie this way as there is still some contrast loss and loss of punch to picture.

 

below is a shot showing some ambient light in the room eg two lamps we have behind line of the screen, again indirect light, not direct on screen. in this case picture was via old epson 9000 series,

 

25821976208_619c806469_b.jpg

 

id go with quarks suggestion re pelmets and make the efforts to control light its well worth it. for not most critical viewing some ambient light in the room likely will be able to get away with 

 

another choice is also as we do which is a drop down screen in front of smaller flat panel which is fine for day to day tv and viewing and we leave the large screen for movies sport, concerts big events  etc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Moderator

oz theatre suggestions a good one, as can get a good package. also check out cleff hifi if in melb. as they sell both jvc and epson. if jvc cant fit budget one of the better epson units might :)

 

ps apart from screen also have to factor in a hdmi cable and decent mount ie the peerless for projectors like the epson/jvc i wouldn't use anything less. installation also if need someone to do all for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Sean84 said:

 

Do grey screens give better daytime performance than white? 

I agree with Al. The only time I'd consider a grey screen nowadays would be if using a cheaper DLP projector with their inherently poorer contrast. For your budget, you're better going for a better projector like the JVC or Sony.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By petetherock
      Item: BenQ W1070 1080p 3D DLP Home Theater Projector
      Location: CBD Sydney
      Price:  $800
      Item Condition: mint 10/10 (less than 250 hours)
      Reason for selling:White elephant - took it out for Christmas - bought on a YOLO moment
      Payment Method: Pickup - Cash deal in CBD, near  JB Hifi George St during Office Hours
      Extra Info: Sold as is, no more warranty, with the box.
       
      Pictures:
       
       
    • By LWA Staff
      Item: Meridian MF10 Projector
      Location: LWA HQ @ 64 Burns Bay Road, Lane Cove, NSW 2066
      Price: $1500
      Item Condition: Very good (2nd hand) condition - with remote.
      Payment Method: Cash, Paypal, Credit Cards, Bank Transfer, Gold Bullion, No goats.
      Extra Info: This was an expensive proposition when new but very good buying now.
      Quiet in operation - this particular example has only 133 hours on the lamp!
      Developed with JVC, this Full HD Projector uses D-ILA light-engine technology, w/ three-chip 1080p array.
      Offers a native contrast ratio of 1:30,000. Picture size from 60 to 200 inches with 2x zoom, 6 meter throw and 2.35:1 conversion capability.
      Tech Specs:
      Input terminals = HDMI x 2 (ver. 1.3), Component x 1 (3 RCA) can also be used as an RGB terminal. S Video terminal (mini DIN4 pin) x 1, Composite x 1 (1 RCA terminal)
      Control terminals = RS-232 (D-sub, 9-pin)
      Video input formats = 480i/p, 576i/p, 720p 60/50, 1080i 60/50, 1080p 60/50/24,
      Dimensions 455 x 172.5 x 418.5mm - Weight 1 1.6kg (25.6 lbs.
      Pictures:



    • By lonewolf
      Item: Epson EH-TW3000
      Location: Sydney
      Price: $700
      Item Condition: Excellent 9/10
      Reason for selling: Too many projectors
      Payment Method: Pickup - Cash, Paypal, COD Only
      Extra Info:
       
      Awesome 1080p LCD Projector. Great Lens Shift and Zoom features. Seems to be able to create very large pictures and from various angles. When not having a dedicated room and requiring a lot of lens shift and zooming features then i think nothing seems to beat the LCD projectors.
      Specs:
      Brightness (Lumens) : 1800 ANSI
      Color Light Output (Lumens) : 1800 ANSI
      Eco-Mode (Lumens): 481 ANSI
      Color Light Output (eco) : 481 ANSI
      Contrast (Full On/Off) : 18000:1
      Variable Iris: Yes
      High Brightness:
      ANSI Lumens: **
      Contrast Ratio: **
      High Contrast:
      ANSI Lumens: **
      Contrast Ratio: 18000:1
      Audible Noise: 28.0 dB
      Eco-Mode: 22.0 dB
      Weight: 7.3 kg
      Size (cm) (HxWxD) : 14 x 45 x 36
      Std. Lens: Focus:
      **
      Zoom: Yes
      Throw Dist (m) : 1.9 - 6.0
      Image Size (cm) : 76 - 508
      Optional Lenses: No
      Digital Zoom: **
      Digital Keystone: **
      Lens Shift: Horz & Vert
      Warranty: 3 Years
      Performance:
      H-Sync Range: **
      V-Sync Range: **
      Compatibility:
      HDTV: 720p, 1080i, 1080p/60
      EDTV/480p: Yes
      SDTV/480i: Yes
      Component Video: Yes
      Video: Yes
      Digital Input: HDMI
      Computers: Yes
      Display: Type:
      2 cm 3 LCD
      Native: 1920x1080 Pixels
      Maximum: 1920x1080 Pixels
      Aspect Ratio: 16:9 (HD)
      Light Source: Type:
      200W E-TORL
      Life: 4000 hours
      Quantity: 1
      Speakers: No
      Max Power: 282W
      Voltage: 100V - 240V
      FCC Class: B
      Reviews:
      http://www.whathifi....epson-eh-tw3000
      http://www.projector...iewehtw3000.htm
      http://www.goodgearg...h-tw3000/296465
       

      Pictures:
       
       
    • By Steven_James89
      Hey Guys,
       
      Recently upgraded my JVC X7000 to the NEW X7900 and a step up over two models leaves me very happy with this unit.
      Aside from the massive face lift in HDR capability the low lag input is an absolute bonus as I game as much as watch movies.
       
      Straight out of the box with factory setting enabled I cant really complain however just wanted to see if anyone has any info as to what is the best mode for your standard Blu-ray viewing.
      Currently using factory setting for Cinema mode but wonder what the key difference would be between that and the THX settings.
      Looking to have the unit calibrated but very early hours on it so far.
       
      Thanks.
       
    • By Johnny_Boy
      Hi,
       
      I am about to purchase a new 4K TV and was wondering how to connect it to use my UHD player for both my projector and new TV.
       
      Current Equipment all running through my AVR
      Denon 4311 AVR
      - UHD BD Pana UB400
      - PS4
      - Apple TV
      - Fetch Mighty
      - 1080p plasma (soon to be replaced with pana 75EX780A)
      - Epson 9100w projector. 
       
      The only way i can think of running this setup with my existing gear is with a UHD hdmi switch from my UHD BD player that would connect to the TV and AVR. Then use the Audio return channel function to get sound from the TV to the AVR for netflix etc. This would mean i use two imput's on the AVR for the BD player, one for dedicated audio when displaying on the TV, and a section direct sound/video when using the projector. 
       
      Anyone have a better idea? I don't really want to get a switch if i can be helped. 

×