Jump to content


Photo
- - - - -

JLTi KT88 "Unity Coupling" Tube Amplifier


  • Please log in to reply
76 replies to this topic

#1 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 17 April 2009 - 05:43 PM

I had been reading about the JLTi EL34 tube amp for some time and as I am building a pair of full range speakers (don’t ask me to design a crossover!!!) I thought it would be good to have a tube amp in the house for the office.

This was about six months ago and when I finally decided to go ahead early this year I spoke with Joe Rasmussen at JLTi to see what was available. He explained that it would be better to get a KT88 version, considering the power needed to drive the speakers I normally use (86dB sensitivity) and also because the amp design was in fact a dual mono construction that could be used as both an integrated and a power amp.

Joe also explained that it would be cheaper overall if I supplied the base amp rather than him. So, I went out looking for a Yaqin MC100B. Low and behold I found one on SNA and had it sent up for modification. Joe put a lot of time into doing the modification and checked all of the wiring to ensure that even circuits that weren’t being changed were correct.

This amp is now in place and it’s a revelation! The easiest way for me to describe the sound is uncompressed. The soundstage is 3-dimensional and all of the detail is revealed in a way that maintains the integrity of the mix in all instances. What this means is that quiet sounds are still quiet but the dynamic range is such that there is room for all the music.

The midrange is superb, which is what tubes have always been good at. The wonderful experience of having the singer in the room is something I have always liked about single ended tube amps. I had a listening session with a lot of different female vocalists and the realism was breathtaking. The highs are wonderful and it is so much easier to discern lyrics that were previously difficult to comprehend. The bass is powerful and authoritative making the whole sonic spectrum balanced and non-fatiguing.

In comparing with my Pioneer SC LX-81, which is no slouch, there is now a wonderful depth to the music. Hearing the breath that surrounds the singer’s voice and the sustained vibration of acoustic guitar brings drama and realism to music.

I haven’t had time to try out all the configurations for this amp. I am currently using the Pioneer as the preamp (it has a remote) and the JLTi KT88 as a power amp, driving my SF Concertos. I would also like to try it as an integrated and also with a different preamp as well as with different speakers. I am already very pleased with the results and can’t begin to say how involving it is to listen to music with this amp.

The modification cost $880 plus freight. A Yaqin MC100B costs less than $1000 so it all works out at less than $2000 for an amazing musical experience. I don’t know if this amp will find its way to the office after all. I look forward to enjoying tube amps all over again


http://www.customana...m/jlti_el34.htm
if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#2 Orpheus

Orpheus

    Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 3,978 posts
  • Location: NSW
  • Country: Australia

Posted 17 April 2009 - 06:08 PM

Excellent result, and impressive looking amp.

#3 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 17 April 2009 - 07:34 PM

Thanks for the nice 'review' and if I may say so, I told you that you'd like it. :)

Cheers.

Joe R.

PS: Will put details on the website plus pic asap.

#4 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 18 April 2009 - 08:46 AM

http://www.stereo.ne...p?t=13480Before sending the amp, took this pic:



Posted Image



Joe R.

Edited by Joe Rasmussen, 18 April 2009 - 08:49 AM.
pic wrong path


#5 Leon

Leon

    Member

  • Members
  • 1,242 posts
  • Location: NSW

Posted 18 April 2009 - 03:27 PM

Hi Joe,

Welcome to the forum, good to have you here, how's things? Just before anyone complains, you may want to read the forum's site guidelines regarding commercial members...
Leon Gross
Soundlabs Group
Mundorf, Visaton, Monacor, Auricap, DACT, Raysonic, Eichmann, JohnBlue, Leben and much more...
Ph. (02) 4627-8766

#6 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 18 April 2009 - 07:07 PM

Hi Leon

Hey, didn't know you inhabited this space. Actually things are very busy indeed, so no complaints except for working too many hours. OK, will take a look at the guidelines, I suppose you are similar in that respect. It's a bit like a member of ASoN and not being blatant and also reasonable about it and just contributing. Actually 'Antripodean' phoned me and just put faith in me as we have an amusing chatter about life and things. :)

Joe R.

#7 Keith_W

Keith_W

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • 9,729 posts
  • Location: VIC

Posted 18 April 2009 - 07:22 PM

Antripodean - that sounds great! Would like to know what modifications were done?

Thanks for pointing him to the guidelines, Leon :)

#8 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 18 April 2009 - 08:36 PM

Hi Keith
Joe says it better on his website, hence the link, but in short it features "Super Linear Triode Mode", "Induced Permeability" & "Unity Coupling". All of this needs far more explanation than I can muster :) What attracted me to the whole modification was no negative feedback, (a feature of your Cary amp), pentodes acting as triodes (I like the power of PP with the sound of SE) and the idea that the output transformer would always be operating in its optimum range.

I could suggest a listen at my place but given your other gear I think it would be more fun to bring the JLTi KT88 over one weekend for a comparison with the Cary CAD 211. I don't mind losing the contest
:)

I had a thought that maybe this thread should be moved to reviews. Leave that with you



if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#9 Keith_W

Keith_W

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • 9,729 posts
  • Location: VIC

Posted 18 April 2009 - 10:12 PM

If you want me to move the thread to reviews, happy to do so :) In fact i'll do it now.

I was a bit puzzled how Joe managed to convert the pentodes to work in triode mode without losing power. Typically you lose about 50% power output by doing this? I had a look at the website and Joe talks about "hiding" the screen grid - an explanation which more or less went over my head :)

In any case, any hope I had of Joe modifying my triode amp is now out the window!

Apart from (maybe) installing that Linearity Enhancement Module. Hmmm.

If you're in Melbourne, I wouldn't mind exchanging visits?

#10 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 19 April 2009 - 08:07 AM

The really interesting part of the modification is that it is not actually a conversion to triode mode, rather it is virtual triode mode. So it's a PP behaving like an SE in effect. I used to have an 845 SE and it is not 'euphonic' like that amp was (which can actually be fun). The explanations go way over my head too but it does come down to 'hiding' the screen grid to achieve this.

Joe is good to talk with about whether something should or could be modified, especially with tube amps. I am always looking for value in hifi so it was an easy decision to go the whole hog, so to speak, rather than spending money on simply changing the wiring which wouldn't have brought the improvements I was looking for.
if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#11 scuzzii

scuzzii

    Member

  • Members
  • 2,093 posts
  • Location: NSW

Posted 19 April 2009 - 08:49 AM

I had been reading about the JLTi EL34 tube amp for some time and as I am building a pair of full range speakers (don’t ask me to design a crossover!!!) I thought it would be good to have a tube amp in the house for the office.

This was about six months ago and when I finally decided to go ahead early this year I spoke with Joe Rasmussen at JLTi to see what was available. He explained that it would be better to get a KT88 version, considering the power needed to drive the speakers I normally use (86dB sensitivity) and also because the amp design was in fact a dual mono construction that could be used as both an integrated and a power amp.

Joe also explained that it would be cheaper overall if I supplied the base amp rather than him. So, I went out looking for a Yaqin MC100B. Low and behold I found one on SNA and had it sent up for modification. Joe put a lot of time into doing the modification and checked all of the wiring to ensure that even circuits that weren’t being changed were correct.

This amp is now in place and it’s a revelation! The easiest way for me to describe the sound is uncompressed. The soundstage is 3-dimensional and all of the detail is revealed in a way that maintains the integrity of the mix in all instances. What this means is that quiet sounds are still quiet but the dynamic range is such that there is room for all the music.

The midrange is superb, which is what tubes have always been good at. The wonderful experience of having the singer in the room is something I have always liked about single ended tube amps. I had a listening session with a lot of different female vocalists and the realism was breathtaking. The highs are wonderful and it is so much easier to discern lyrics that were previously difficult to comprehend. The bass is powerful and authoritative making the whole sonic spectrum balanced and non-fatiguing.

In comparing with my Pioneer SC LX-81, which is no slouch, there is now a wonderful depth to the music. Hearing the breath that surrounds the singer’s voice and the sustained vibration of acoustic guitar brings drama and realism to music.

I haven’t had time to try out all the configurations for this amp. I am currently using the Pioneer as the preamp (it has a remote) and the JLTi KT88 as a power amp, driving my SF Concertos. I would also like to try it as an integrated and also with a different preamp as well as with different speakers. I am already very pleased with the results and can’t begin to say how involving it is to listen to music with this amp.

The modification cost $880 plus freight. A Yaqin MC100B costs less than $1000 so it all works out at less than $2000 for an amazing musical experience. I don’t know if this amp will find its way to the office after all. I look forward to enjoying tube amps all over again


http://www.customana...m/jlti_el34.htm



Great review.

Did you swap tubes over as well or are you still using stock ones?

I wonder if Joe can mod a Melody SP9......:D

Couldn't help but notice the SACD players on his site.

#12 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 19 April 2009 - 12:34 PM

I am using stock tubes at this stage. I didn't want to introduce more variables and more expense :) at this stage. Joe assures me that I can go tube rolling in the future :D

I think if you have a schematic for the Melody then I am sure it can be modified. I always think starting with a good amp and making it even better is an excellent strategy. My Yaqin has been dragged kicking and screaming out of the 1950s :D

I have the JLTi modded Oppo and it sounds great. I only have 4 SACDs but it sounds superb. Out with the jitter and in with the music!
if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#13 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 19 April 2009 - 03:20 PM

Hi Keith
Joe says it better on his website, hence the link, but in short it features "Super Linear Triode Mode", "Induced Permeability" & "Unity Coupling".


I have decided not to use Super Linear Triode Mode as that term is also used to describe another technique used by another designer (who graciously publishes his circuits). But I found that Virtual Triode Operation has been used to correctly describe it, hence VTO.

But VTO on its own has not been universally accepted when others have tried it. I do believe and have floated this on another place, that VTO gets exposes the output transformer and its low level lack of resolution, especially with the most common type which is silicon steel cores (other cores are very expensive when used as power outputs). The LEM module constantly keeps the transformer busy, so much so that any audio signal below about 60dB SPL (soft but clearly audible) keeps having the same Permeability and hence resolution. It will surprise many that tube output transformers have a strong similarity with DACs used in digital playback: At very low level they have poor resolution.

The beauty is that it complements VTO. Where VTO adds real dynamics and power (in an audio and not measured sense) it can also sound just a bit uncouth and rough-and-ready because it exposes other short-comings. The LEM adds the opposite, the matching refinement that comes from better linearity. Sound wise 1+1 now equals 3 or 4 and not 2.

Most amplifiers that are routed in 50's technology (and that applies to almost all PP amplifiers using Pentodes like KT88, 6550, EL34 and so on) can be converted. But the Unity Coupling can be tricky as it relies on getting rid of global feedback. The gain goes up dramatically and some way needs to be found to lower gain and also fix the raised noise floor that results. But I have done this to a variety of amps, from Jadis to Dynaco and the new (and fantastic value) Chinese Yaqin amplifiers.

The Yaqins also gets a 'constant current source' on the driver stage. The SRPP input stage sounds nice but I have real problems with it - sounds oh so smooth and oh so boring in the long run. This gets converted into a classic single Triode voltage gain stage - it may be classic but this into a high impedance load on the Anode means current is almost constant and sound quite glorious (note my repeated use of the phrase "constant current" - this is high in my audio vocabulary). This is one thing we don't need to reinvent.

Anybody in Sydney (or visiting) is welcome to drop in and have a listen. Guys (and gals) who come here know that they will not get any exposure to pressure salesmanship. Bring CDs, SACDs or vinyl and we have fun listening to music and it gives me a break from work. :D

Joe R.

#14 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 19 April 2009 - 03:33 PM

Great review.

Did you swap tubes over as well or are you still using stock ones?

I wonder if Joe can mod a Melody SP9......:D

Couldn't help but notice the SACD players on his site.


On the first one, always keep the tubes that was used to set up the amp in the first place, don't burn any bridges. But in most cases cooking with tubes is OK, but sometimes it can lead to unexpected results. Also change the tubes in stages and never all at the same time.

Re the Melody SP9, its tube complement of KT88 etc leads me to think that it is doable. Nice looking attenuator using Beyschlag resistors (pic on their website). That's the brand of resistor I use as well. This amp is likely Ultra-Linear, so expect half power when converted to VTO (or any other form of Triode), but it wound sound half power, promise.

SACD players? Different subject...

Joe R.

#15 mwhouston

mwhouston

    Member

  • Members
  • 715 posts
  • Location: Southern Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Mark

Posted 13 May 2009 - 12:05 AM

I had been reading about the JLTi EL34 tube amp for some time and as I am building a pair of full range speakers (don’t ask me to design a crossover!!!) I thought it would be good to have a tube amp in the house for the office.

This was about six months ago and when I finally decided to go ahead early this year I spoke with Joe Rasmussen at JLTi to see what was available. He explained that it would be better to get a KT88 version, considering the power needed to drive the speakers I normally use (86dB sensitivity) and also because the amp design was in fact a dual mono construction that could be used as both an integrated and a power amp.

Joe also explained that it would be cheaper overall if I supplied the base amp rather than him. So, I went out looking for a Yaqin MC100B. Low and behold I found one on SNA and had it sent up for modification. Joe put a lot of time into doing the modification and checked all of the wiring to ensure that even circuits that weren’t being changed were correct.

This amp is now in place and it’s a revelation! The easiest way for me to describe the sound is uncompressed. The soundstage is 3-dimensional and all of the detail is revealed in a way that maintains the integrity of the mix in all instances. What this means is that quiet sounds are still quiet but the dynamic range is such that there is room for all the music.

The midrange is superb, which is what tubes have always been good at. The wonderful experience of having the singer in the room is something I have always liked about single ended tube amps. I had a listening session with a lot of different female vocalists and the realism was breathtaking. The highs are wonderful and it is so much easier to discern lyrics that were previously difficult to comprehend. The bass is powerful and authoritative making the whole sonic spectrum balanced and non-fatiguing.

In comparing with my Pioneer SC LX-81, which is no slouch, there is now a wonderful depth to the music. Hearing the breath that surrounds the singer’s voice and the sustained vibration of acoustic guitar brings drama and realism to music.

I haven’t had time to try out all the configurations for this amp. I am currently using the Pioneer as the preamp (it has a remote) and the JLTi KT88 as a power amp, driving my SF Concertos. I would also like to try it as an integrated and also with a different preamp as well as with different speakers. I am already very pleased with the results and can’t begin to say how involving it is to listen to music with this amp.

The modification cost $880 plus freight. A Yaqin MC100B costs less than $1000 so it all works out at less than $2000 for an amazing musical experience. I don’t know if this amp will find its way to the office after all. I look forward to enjoying tube amps all over again


http://www.customana...m/jlti_el34.htm


After having built a KT88 SE UL amp and even after having to run EL34s in place I can agree that these amps are incredibly good sounding. I had to use (originally 5881s) EL34s because I cut the base whole too small. The cct. I am using is going to be very different to what has been run in this thread but SE UL pentodes produce, not only exceptionally good music but 3D sound staging.

I had built a few Spare Time Gizmo’s 6T9 amps and loved the sound stage and clarity. This got me to build this amp which supports Edcor XSE (inexpensive) OPTs, diode rec. (not enough room for valve rec. with choke filtering) all on a big timber base. The schematic is very simple. It has to be to let the music through. I am now supporting a matched pair of Black Sable EL34s. It just got better.

Though this is not a Vacuum State upgraded amp I can only support the call for SE UL pentode designs. The whole timbre of my system has changed like never (and I mean never) before. Now to build a good one.

Edited by mwhouston, 13 May 2009 - 12:11 AM.
missed some detail


#16 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 15 May 2009 - 03:19 PM

I have to say I agree with you :) Running the KT88s in triode mode is sounding great. It's great that you are building your own amps. Opens up a world of possibilities and modding.

BTW I heard there was a recent 'amp blind shoot out' at the Audio Society of NSW (ASON) and the JLTi Vacuum State modded EL34 came up as the winner :P I am waiting to read a write up on the site but I understand it was up against SS and other tube amps. I like that it was a blind test and I am interested in their methodology as well.
if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#17 A9X

A9X

    The Adonis of SNA

  • Members
  • 3,287 posts
  • Location: Sinny
  • Country: This one
  • First Name:Sir

Posted 15 May 2009 - 04:26 PM

BTW I heard there was a recent 'amp blind shoot out' at the Audio Society of NSW (ASON) and the JLTi Vacuum State modded EL34 came up as the winner :rolleyes: I am waiting to read a write up on the site but I understand it was up against SS and other tube amps. I like that it was a blind test and I am interested in their methodology as well.

I hope that's available online sometime. I'm curious about these amps mainly because I've built most of Allen's preamps and the PP1C and PP2C poweramps; then modified them. Some of the first 'audiohile' tube gear I built from schematics Allen gave me years ago.
Not sure who designed this beast, but there will be a fair amount of VS influence I expect.
I don't 'do' smilies or much IMO etc. Please presume they are there, along with humour and irony.

I also take NO responsibility for your emotional response to something I might type.

#18 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 15 May 2009 - 07:31 PM

I hope that's available online sometime. I'm curious about these amps mainly because I've built most of Allen's preamps and the PP1C and PP2C poweramps; then modified them. Some of the first 'audiohile' tube gear I built from schematics Allen gave me years ago.
Not sure who designed this beast, but there will be a fair amount of VS influence I expect.


I can tell you that the Vacuum State schematics you have built not only have Allen Wright in them, but also a LOT of Joe Rasmussen in them. Indeed I built the first PP1C design/schematic into an old Dyna EL34 amp and got Allen to listen to it. There is a lot more... we go back a long time.

BTW, it says you are a westie, so am I. That is what we here in Sydney West call ourselves, so is that where you are too.

Cheers.

Joe R.

#19 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 15 May 2009 - 07:35 PM

MY COMPUTER CRASHED!!!

At least one person with an existing power amp emailed me directly the morning my hard drive, only two months old, went belly-up in seconds. Lost record of all emails since February 15. Not able to reply as I don't have email addresses. Dar'n it!

Joe R.


#20 andyr

andyr

    Member

  • Members
  • 4,812 posts
  • Location: VIC
  • Country: Australia

Posted 15 May 2009 - 10:38 PM

MY COMPUTER CRASHED!!!

At least one person with an existing power amp emailed me directly the morning my hard drive, only two months old, went belly-up in seconds. Lost record of all emails since February 15. Not able to reply as I don't have email addresses. Dar'n it!

Joe R.


C'mon, Joe,

You haven't backed up your PC since Feb 15 ... shame on you! :rolleyes:

Once a week's good (as the actress said to the bishop) but, realistically, once a month is probably reasonable. :cool:

Regards,

Andy

#21 A9X

A9X

    The Adonis of SNA

  • Members
  • 3,287 posts
  • Location: Sinny
  • Country: This one
  • First Name:Sir

Posted 16 May 2009 - 11:40 AM

I can tell you that the Vacuum State schematics you have built not only have Allen Wright in them, but also a LOT of Joe Rasmussen in them. Indeed I built the first PP1C design/schematic into an old Dyna EL34 amp and got Allen to listen to it. There is a lot more... we go back a long time.

Allen told me you designed the crappy bits, which he designed out when you weren't looking.

BTW, it says you are a westie, so am I. That is what we here in Sydney West call ourselves, so is that where you are too.

Cheers.

Joe R.

My therapist told me I had to post my location that way, to come to terms with the reality of it all and deal with the shame. How can a Northern Beaches boy have fallen so far?
Though, I must admit the Winnie Reds in the AC/DC T shirt thing is pretty cool.
I don't 'do' smilies or much IMO etc. Please presume they are there, along with humour and irony.

I also take NO responsibility for your emotional response to something I might type.

#22 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 18 May 2009 - 07:52 AM

C'mon, Joe,

You haven't backed up your PC since Feb 15 ... shame on you! :o

Once a week's good...


I am now backing up every day, no excuses.

Joe R.

#23 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 18 May 2009 - 07:57 AM

Allen told me you designed the crappy bits, which he designed out when you weren't looking.


Well, I am looking and the crappy bits are still there. Maybe not so crappy after all. :o

My therapist told me I had to post my location that way, to come to terms with the reality of it all and deal with the shame. How can a Northern Beaches boy have fallen so far?
Though, I must admit the Winnie Reds in the AC/DC T shirt thing is pretty cool.


So when are you coming and visiting me? Just look on the map and see where the M5 and M7 meet and there I am. BTW, I used to be an Eastie, but the cost of building a house... well, you know what I mean. I miss Maroubra Beach.

Joe R.

Edited by Joe Rasmussen, 18 May 2009 - 07:58 AM.
... because I make mistakes :-(


#24 mwhouston

mwhouston

    Member

  • Members
  • 715 posts
  • Location: Southern Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Mark

Posted 18 May 2009 - 08:09 AM

Since my last (and first) post concerning Valve, SE UL amps I have upgraded my Electro-Harmonix tubes to Black Sables. Yes another Vodka swilling tube but these are both matched and cryogenically treated.

Usually tubes take 50 hours of play to get them to really settle. Not the Sables. These came out guns blazing to make a sonic impression not easily forgotten Now not only had I depth around individual performers or whole groups that depth had extended laterally to the total width of the sound stage.

For a few hundred dollars these are well worth it. They replaced a pair of date matched only common tubes but not electrically matched tubes. To gain the finest detail in music and to paint an expansive 3D sound stage the tubes have to be matched and the amp built with a perfect balance of channels. My sound stage 'tends to hover in mid air and extend way behind the wall to which the speakers back. This "hover" pleases most listeners though some prefer a more solid sound scape. For me I like the feeling the sound is being projected into the space between my Osborn Eclipse.

I also bought a pair of NOS Siemens rumored to be the best of the EL34s. Yet to be auditioned.

#25 A9X

A9X

    The Adonis of SNA

  • Members
  • 3,287 posts
  • Location: Sinny
  • Country: This one
  • First Name:Sir

Posted 18 May 2009 - 08:14 AM

Well, I am looking and the crappy bits are still there. Maybe not so crappy after all. :o

Some years ago, maybe 01 or 02, you sent me some info about techniques for forcing balance in O/P stages. Is the current amp a development of that?
I can't recall what you called it, but I did find the papers in my filing cab during the move.

So when are you coming and visiting me? Just look on the map and see where the M5 and M7 meet and there I am. BTW, I used to be an Eastie, but the cost of building a house... well, you know what I mean. I miss Maroubra Beach.

Joe R.

I'm out here for the same reasons. I miss Narra and North Curlie the most.

Well, I'd sure like to come and have a listen. I gave a mate who's interested in the Elsinores, and I'm currently working at Hoxton, but even so it's not that far from home. I'll give you a call soon when I'm sure of my exact movements to arrange.

Cheers.
I don't 'do' smilies or much IMO etc. Please presume they are there, along with humour and irony.

I also take NO responsibility for your emotional response to something I might type.

#26 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 25 May 2009 - 12:22 PM

Some years ago, maybe 01 or 02, you sent me some info about techniques for forcing balance in O/P stages. Is the current amp a development of that?


Both yes and no. It's a long story... so much water under the bridge since then. We are about three to four steps further down the road since then.


Some years ago, maybe 01 or 02, you sent me some info about techniques for forcing balance in O/P stages. Is the current amp a development of that?

Well, I'd sure like to come and have a listen. I gave a mate who's interested in the Elsinores, and I'm currently working at Hoxton, but even so it's not that far from home. I'll give you a call soon when I'm sure of my exact movements to arrange.


Why don't both of you call. Hoxton is minutes away from here (but give me a bit more than that advance notice). Bring some music as well.

Cheers.

Joe R.

#27 Antripodean

Antripodean

    Member

  • Members
  • 606 posts
  • Location: Victoria
  • Country: Australia
  • First Name:Roger

Posted 26 May 2009 - 07:06 AM

I follow with a summary of the amp shootout. This is the tube one and the winner of this was put up against the winner of the solid state amp shootout. Please enjoy :rolleyes:

VALVES OR SOLID STATE?
We have a decisive winner!
Source: Primare CD player (as used in the solid state amplifier shootout)
Preamp: NuForce P9 (2 box) preamplifier
Valve amplifiers: (in order of audition on the day)
1. Cymer 13E1 push-pull monoblocs (70W/ch) (Elson) ($1600)
2. Cary 2A3 push-pull stereo (7.6W/ch) (David Cooper)
3. JLTi rebuild of Chinese integrated, 2 pairs EL34 in triode mode (Joe R) ($1600)
4. VTL 45/45, 2 pairs EL34 in ultralinear mode (Stephen Chen) ($4500)
5. Copland 501 (Walter Koll)
Speakers: Orpheus Aurora 3 (kindly supplied by Kiat Low of Duntech and Orpheus)
Cables: as used in the solid state amplifier shootout, 5 identical pairs of unbalanced interconnect and flat Nordost speaker cable (bi-wire)
Aim (paraphrasing John Sawley’s introduction in the April Newsletter)
At this meeting we compared the various valve amplifiers and determined a winner.
We then compared the winner to the solid state winner, the AKSA, from the meeting two months ago. This was a lot of fun and gave members an idea of what is out there in the market place at various price points and what they sound like.
The problem with shootouts is that although they are informative and give a basic understanding of the bang you get for your buck, they do not give you an understanding of what they sound like in a fully tweaked and fine tuned system. If you are interested in listening to a more finely tuned (and synergistic) system, how about asking other members what systems they own? Then invite yourself around for a listen. I’m sure most members would be delighted to show off their systems to you and then you will be better able to judge for yourself in a friendly domestic environment,
what the various components sound like when tweaked to that member’s taste. It’s also a great time and a lot of fun.
Last Month’s Meeting
Methodology
For the first stage, 1½ minutes from the same three tracks were played on each of the 5 amplifiers in turn, which were identified by number only, and blinded to the audience.
Levels were matched with Joe Rasmussen’s SPL meter.
For the second stage, 1½ minutes were played, with the order of the amplifiers selected at random.
All members scored each track out of ten, as in the previous meeting; compiled the scores, and ranked the amplifiers. The rankings of all members were then compiled to determine the overall winner.
And the winner is>.. JLTi integrated, by a decisive margin!
The runners up were:
2. VTL
3. Copland
4. Cary
5. Cymer
Discussion
These were some of my thoughts during the process, not being able to identify which amplifier was which. I personally thought that many of the recordings were too closemiked and strident for my liking. This removed some of the discriminatory value for the process, however, having said that, a good amplifier should have the resolving power to clearly distinguish good from bad recordings and performances.
Amplifier 1, I found to be detailed but strident and lacking in bass. Amplifier 2 had a giveaway from behind the screen, saying that the gain was close to maximum. There were sonic giveaways with the frequency balance being all midrange, not much at the extremes and discontinuousness. Amplifier 3 was the frontrunner from the beginning being more continuous and seamless from lows to highs. Amplifier 4 started slowly but picked up as the survey continued. Amplifier 5, I found to be bass heavy.

Tube versus transistor
3 successive tracks were played on each of the 2 amplifiers with the audience being again blinded.
1. (great track, but sorry no one can remember its name)
2. Keb Mo’
3. Neil Young: Old Man (live version) – my musical highlight
I found the first one smoother and the second one to have a more nasal quality to the voices; more detailed but etched. I guessed right in a 2 horse race and so did the majority of the audience who preferred the sound of the tubed to the transistor amp.
So, congratulations Joe, maybe some justice has been done after the low ranking of your CD player in the shootout.
Conclusion
Being the owner of the VTL, I acknowledge that the JLTi did sound better on the day.
Possible explanations could be:
1. The inherently sound (pdp) design of the Chinese amplifier which makes it amenable to modification
2. The improved linearity due to the permeability enhancer (I will give serious consideration to having this mod done)
3. Operation in triode mode
One limitation of the study was the absence of really complex music, like orchestral and choir or pipe organ.
I know that this would not make it past my hospital’s ethics committee but writing this like a scientific paper is my idea of fun!
Stephen Chen
if it clicks, pops, buzzes or hums it isn't hifi! ...unless it's analogue ;)
DISCLAIMER: I own over 500 records :D

#28 awhw

awhw

    Member

  • Members
  • 288 posts
  • Location: NSW

Posted 26 May 2009 - 01:15 PM

Interesting read. Thanks!

#29 bronal

bronal

    Member

  • Members
  • 2,124 posts
  • Location: ACT

Posted 26 May 2009 - 06:02 PM

This thread is looking more like an advertorial with every post.

I notice all of Joe Rasmussen's posts to date are in this thread.

#30 Joe Rasmussen

Joe Rasmussen

    Member

  • Members
  • 82 posts
  • Location: New South Wales

Posted 01 June 2009 - 10:23 AM

This thread is looking more like an advertorial with every post.

I notice all of Joe Rasmussen's posts to date are in this thread.


I am sorry you feel this way. That certainly has not been my intention. Note that I did not initiate this thread and what others have posted they have done so unsolicited. I think the above contributors will attest to that. Please read the entire thread and you will see that I have only being responding to other posts and not conducting a drive.

If anybody wants to offer a critique of anything that I have made or have a hand in, they are quite free to do so. I expose myself to both praise and criticism.

Re the ASoN Amp Shoot-out I was asked to participate. When the ASoN Newsletter came out I posted it on my website last week. That's all. If others wish to quote my website, that is their prerogative.

Cheers.

Joe R.